HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

em-bee

10,499 karma · joined August 27, 2018

software developer / trainer / mentor / CTO on demand

contact me for mentorship, training or project work opportunities:

embee+hn at societyserver dot net

submissionscomments
em-bee··on California bans child marriage, a practice still legal in 32 US states
would you mind sharing the country/culture? as i said elsewhere, in china people also marry and have children young, and they are ready. but they also have a lot of support from their parents and society. young couples normally live with their parents who help them raise the children and run the household, allowing the young couple to learn but also focus on work and career.
em-bee··on Memory Companies Have Destroyed the Consumer Market
but if the AI RAM market is so much more profitable than the consumer RAM market, who is going to buy consumer RAM futures?

to buy consumer RAM futures i would have to predict the price the RAM can be sold at 5 or 10 years from now. that seems very risky. why would i do that instead of buying AI RAM instead?

em-bee··on California bans child marriage, a practice still legal in 32 US states
but then it's not the age that made the difference, but the focus in your life. you had other interests, and that also told you that it's not the right time for you to have children. not everyone has the same focus at 23. i wasn't interested in getting married at 23 either. but other people are. did your wife's parents want to have children that early, or was that unplanned? you don't need to answer, but i think that question makes a difference. i don't believe people chose to have children if they don't feel ready for it.
em-bee··on California bans child marriage, a practice still legal in 32 US states
wikipedia lists 18 european countries where the minimum age is 18 without exception. some of which changed that only recently.
em-bee··on California bans child marriage, a practice still legal in 32 US states
When a minor marries someone of age, their spouse becomes their legal guardian until they become of age (or become emancipated, which is a difficult process generally).

that sounds totally wrong. not as in you are wrong, but as in this reality is bad. apparently, according to wikipedia at least in some US states, marriage automatically emancipates a minor, but not in massachusetts.

em-bee··on California bans child marriage, a practice still legal in 32 US states
how does that protect 18yr olds from being forced into marriage? a 16yr old can not consent but an 18yr old can? i was hardly any smarter at 18 than i was at 16. in my opinion the problem is not the consent or lack thereof, or the age, the problem is the inability legally or maturity wise, to say "no".

with the right culture and support there is nothing wrong with getting married early.

the problem comes from arranged marriages, especially if there is a large age difference.

instead of setting a minimum age, which does not help much, it should be easier to refuse, and even if agreed, it should be possible for anyone under say 25 to simply have a marriage annulled or a divorce if there are obvious problems (such as the age difference).

but if both are young, then marrying young has its benefits. the younger we are the more adaptable we are, and that helps to build a relationship and makes it easier to get along.

the idea that we should be fully matured adults before getting married doesn't actually work, because living together is part of the process of maturing, and the older you are the more difficult is it to develop certain skills and attitudes that you need for a successful marriage.

in china, people get married much earlier than in the west, but they also have strong family and social support for doing so.

em-bee··on What is the size of Yemen? (2024)
i figured there was some connection, but i didn't expect the author to be involved because i would have expected that they update the article and mention that they found a document and fixed wikipedia.
em-bee··on Memory Companies Have Destroyed the Consumer Market
exactly this. and this is why, in the long run, we not only need to eliminate poverty, but also extreme wealth.
em-bee··on Memory Companies Have Destroyed the Consumer Market
the market can't fix this. the problem here is that the consumer market is dwarfed by big buyers. the consumer market is simply less profitable. traditionally when a market is no longer profitable enough for big businesses, it opens the room for new small businesses to step in. but that won't work here unless someone finds a way to make small fabs profitable.
em-bee··on If we do not stop to help each other, what do we become?
part of the problem of figuring this out is the kind of transaction happening. you seem to define the transaction as something that needs to be evenly distributed among all members. because as i understand it, that's the only way the premise can be corrupted, by producing uneven (unfair?) outputs for the members.

but i see that differently. people join a group because they get something out of it, sure. but what they get out of it is being part of a community and contributing to a common goal. that some people contribute more and others less does not matter. at least in the groups i was or am in. we joined the linux user group because we believe in the ideals of FOSS. some may help others, but that's not the reason for joining. same goes for religious groups. the goal of those groups, the motivation to participate is not the transaction. it's the belief in the underlying principles. these groups will fall apart if they fail to attract new members, but the ideals, if they matter, will survive.

em-bee··on On caring for user data: NeoVim caused Vim undo files to be deleted
it's not the default place, it's where the user decided to put it.
em-bee··on Malleable software: Restoring user agency in a world of locked-down apps (2025)
that's what the AGPL is for.
em-bee··on If we do not stop to help each other, what do we become?
ok, i didn't get that from your post. most groups you mention as example are not in that category. except for religious groups (and cults with are a subset of religious groups) none of the groups have any expectation to last. so i don't quite get what your point is.

you argue that the fate of groups is to end when leaders stop putting effort, which is kind of self evident unless there is an underlying premise that is able to outlast the individual groups. my group was effectively dead before i took over. i rebuilt it almost from scratch. that was only possible because it was based on an underlying idea that others could identify with that was not dependent on my person. FOSS groups come and go but the FOSS community as a whole won't ever die. same goes for religion. at least the kind of religion that is based on written word.

why is a 75 year old organization not old enough? given that members can join at most 15 years, that's already 5 generations.

you also argue that the only thing that makes groups last is money or social status. if that were the case most groups would not even start.

i understand your personal experience, and that's fine, but that has nothing to do with multi generational organizations. it seems to me that you are mixing two unrelated things here.

em-bee··on Kidnapping kids remains legal in USA, this site has you experience it first-hand
i agree this should absolutely be illegal. especially at the age of these children who are usually teenagers and should have some rights.
em-bee··on I'm the mom in that viral Giants clip. Let me tell you about my husband
covid made the wearing of masks publicly acceptable. in western culture it used to be unwelcome. like if you hide your face you must be a criminal. in austria has a contoversial law that made masking your face in public generally illegal.
em-bee··on On caring for user data: NeoVim caused Vim undo files to be deleted
vim: Undo files are normally saved in the same directory as the file

neovim: by default they are saved to the dedicated directory in the application data folder

I think a user could be forgiven for assuming that it was fine to use the same value when trying out a migration from vim to neovim

neovim would also overwrite its own old version of the file. the point is that the expectation that neovim should watch out for files that are used by other applications is in my opinion not reasonable. it won't even watch out for its own old undo files.

users may have the expectation that neovim and vim are compatible, but that expectation is simply not entirely fulfilled. you can't share config files unless you have some minimal ones that just happen to work. so why would you be able to share other files?

the question is, how are these expectations formed, and what is reasonable to expect?

when it started out neovim was very compatible with vim. but from my experience with FOSS and based on the stated goal of neovim at least to me it was clear that compatibility was not going to last. not everyone shares that experience, and thus their expectations are different. neovim should perhaps make that more clear and for one be aware that people expect compatibility and warn users accordingly. an argument could be made that if a user changes the undodir value, there is a higher chance that they may try to use the same for vim. but then vim devs would need to do that too.

but does not considering that make devs not good at what they are doing? i don't think so. for one, if someone thinks the devs are not good enough they should stop using neovim (as some people here in the thread announced they are doing. their choice). personally i think this is average for FOSS and good enough. we can't expect everyone to be perfect. the correct response to an issue besides reporting it is not to complain but to contribute a fix.

em-bee··on If we do not stop to help each other, what do we become?
sorry for your experience, but i disagree. first my personal experience is different. i have been in and led groups that survived leadership changes and are still active almost a decade after i left as a leader. i also come from a culture where organizing is a cultural trait strong enough that there is a dedicated legal structure for it. whether community survives or grows depends on the culture the community is created with or instilled by its members. the group i was running was a linux user group where i took over from previous leaders. until i took over the majority of group members were expats, many of which left the country at some point which is how i got to lead the group. i had to rebuild and instilled a culture of delegation and getting others to contribute. i did that until all the work was done by various members and they didn't need me anymore. i stayed with the group until i moved cities. and as i said the group is still active.

my brother was in a group where members had to be less than 27 years of age. in the year of your 27th birthday you became an old sock and left. and despite that this group put out high quality guide books on how to identify plant and animal species which is their main interest. it was founded 75 years ago and is still active. no financial or social standing opportunities to be had.

again, i am sorry for your experience, but this is absolutely not the limit of human society.

em-bee··on If we do not stop to help each other, what do we become?
so you are arguing that once people form a crowd, they lose any sense of direction unless a strong leader steps up and pushes them somewhere?

i think Free Software and Open Source are counter examples. and i bet there are more. FOSS started with a good idea. not with a good leader. i love and respect richard stallman, but he is not a good leader. people follow him because he has a great idea and makes every effort to defend that idea.

the point being: if you have a set of beliefs, principles and you find others that agree, you potentially have something that is strong enough to keep the group on course.

em-bee··on If we do not stop to help each other, what do we become?
and you are not the only one (except for the political label in my case)
em-bee··on If we do not stop to help each other, what do we become?
you could work less if business would allow it, but it doesn't. it is surprisingly hard to find jobs that let you work less than full time. so it's not a siren call, to work more, unless you are selfemployed in which case you do have a choice.
em-bee··on On caring for user data: NeoVim caused Vim undo files to be deleted
vim and neovim have different defaults for the undo file, if neovim overwrites a vim file then it can only be because the user changed the paths for both to be the same. in that case neovim had no way of knowing that the file was used by another program.
em-bee··on Kidnapping kids remains legal in USA, this site has you experience it first-hand
this is horrible and it's against the will of the children but it's not kidnapping as defined by the law.
em-bee··on What is the size of Yemen? (2024)
this was posted on 27. of november 2024. on the 3rd of december someone found a correct looking number in a yemen government document which was published in 2005 and updated wikipedia. so at least the country itself was not under any illusion of being bigger than they actually are.
em-bee··on Silicon Valley 'sex assault list' with 'over 100' names circulated
i forgot to add that i am just talking about general definitions and my own feelings, not your personal specifics. feel free to respond as you feel comfortable
em-bee··on Silicon Valley 'sex assault list' with 'over 100' names circulated
it being normalized doesn't make it normal. the critical point here is that it should not be normal, and the only way to make it not normal is to say so. coming out and repeating that it is normal only helps to normalize it further. in my circles it is not normal. but in part that is because i stay away from people who think it is normal. and it could be that i am in the minority, but i hope not. either way, this needs to be called out and opposed, and my complaint to you is that you are not opposing it.
em-bee··on Silicon Valley 'sex assault list' with 'over 100' names circulated
Women had to be interested in me so that I could feel validated

i don't quite get the meaning of this in the context of accepting agency of others. because it works both ways. either it means you assume that they are interested in you to validate yourself, or it means you need see/experience them actively showing interest in order to validate your approach.

likewise with agency, i can assume someone has agency, which is actually bad because it leads to thinking: if they didn't want this they would have used their agency to stop it. or i can ask myself whether there might be something that could prevent this person from using their agency.

a problem is also that when approaching someone you know what you want, and what you want could be something harmless. but the approached person doesn't know that if they don't know you well enough already.

em-bee··on Silicon Valley 'sex assault list' with 'over 100' names circulated
That's normal behavior by both men and women

no, it isn't. if you think it is then you should look for other friends.

you are reading an awful lot into the comment.

em-bee··on I'm the mom in that viral Giants clip. Let me tell you about my husband
virginia mom is discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49550174
em-bee··on I'm the mom in that viral Giants clip. Let me tell you about my husband
i thought that too, but that's not really a story, that's just normal for the US. in europe (most of the EU i am sure) and china and probably elsewhere it's illegal to lay someone off while they are pregnant. (exceptions exist, and if they apply insurance works also for the unemployed)
em-bee··on Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free
i have no clue what features google play has but my guess is that a simple date check that disables the app after a certain time is possible without using any google play features. so it could be offered as a free app that simply stops working after some time.
Page 1 of 34Next →