HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

eddiepete

1 karma · joined August 23, 2025

eddie@dinogalactic.com

https://dinogalactic.com

submissionscomments
eddiepete··on Formal methods and the future of programming
I wonder how formal methods can help us move faster with GenAI.

Is it that they can help write formulas faster? That they can help ensure formulas match the system they're modeling faster? If the problem you think formal methods will help with is sloppy code, isn't the verification code going to be sloppy as well, unless some (not sloppy) intelligence carefully confirms that the specification matches the target system, which was the labor that previously made formal methods too expensive? I guess I don't understand how the argument works if code was previously less sloppy and verification was too expensive, and now code is more sloppy, and there's more of it, but somehow the sloppy intelligence will make verification move fast enough to make it worthwhile.

Unless we have some non-sloppy intelligence that's less of a bottleneck on verification than humans, how are we in a better place?

Maybe it's that investing that huge amount of labor of verification by human experts is now worth it because so much code will be produced that uses the verification systems that the investment will now pay off. But that requires creating pretty general verification systems, such as type system verification or something (which is what they seem to be aimed at), rather than individually verifying software systems like the micro-kernel example.

In other words, maybe the play is to invest in reusable verification systems that can be run tons of times on new code and systems. If so, it's surprising that this wasn't always the strategy.

eddiepete··on Please Let Me Read – The Web Was Once Good:(
My idea is admittedly half-baked, but I've been thinking of the concept of an alternative web. I don't know how it would work. Ignoring implementation for a second, what if you could stay within a network of non-corporate content, search engines, etc.? I feel like everyday I find neat websites on Hacker News built by real people for fun and community, but then my daily web browsing activity doesn't feel like this. If I do one Google or DuckDuckGo search, I'm inevitably going to land on some site that is at least cluttered with SEO garbage, even if it's an individual person's blog (cooking blogs are a great example). I guess my criteria for what sites would get included in this are not well defined. Maybe I just want the old web back.