HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ed

5,971 karma · joined February 23, 2007

emcmanus -at- gmail
submissionscomments
ed··on GLP-1 drugs linked to lower death rates in colon cancer patients
Source?

There’s growing evidence of cardioprotective effects independent of weight loss.

Eg https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...

> The cardioprotective effects of semaglutide were independent of baseline adiposity and weight loss and had only a small association with waist circumference, suggesting some mechanisms for benefit beyond adiposity reduction.

ed··on Dating: A mysterious constellation of facts
I was suggesting OP may have been influenced by submarine articles since the popularity of speed dating is a potentially unfounded premise of their argument. (Personally, I know very few folks who’ve done speed dating but of course that’s anecdotal.)
ed··on Show HN: Why write code if the LLM can just do the thing? (web app experiment)
Like a lot of people in this thread I prototyped something similar. One experiment just connected GPT to a socket and gave it some bindings to SQLite.

With a system prompt like “you’re an http server for a twitter clone called Gwitter.” you can interact directly with the LLM from a browser.

Of course it was painfully slow, quickly went off the rails, and revealed that LLM’s are bad at business logic.

But something like this might be the future. And on a longer time horizon, mentioned by OP and separately by sama, it may be possible to render interactive apps as streaming video and bypass the browser stack entirely.

So I think we’re a the Mother of All Demos stage of things. These ideas are in the water but not really practical today. Similarly to MoaD, it may take another 25 years for them to come to fruition.

ed··on Dating: A mysterious constellation of facts
I don’t think speed dating is as popular as submarine[1] articles suggest. But the constraint of being in-person and with a limited set of options may be helpful for some people. The paradox of choice is a significant issue on apps.

I do agree that bandwidth is significantly higher in person, we’ve evolved efficient pattern detection, and wish it were more acceptable to meet up for a quick coffee immediately after matching. But a few bad apples spoil the bunch.

There’s an alternate explanation - that the fittest companies prioritize engagement and revenue until reaching some threshold of user dissatisfaction. The healthiest businesses often have customers who wish they could leave, but can’t.

1 - https://paulgraham.com/submarine.html

ed··on In orbit you have to slow down to speed up
> a very costly operation

It's only costly due to the waste heat from breaking. If you captured that energy with perfect regenerative breaking you could return to the same speed in the opposite direction. (In a spherical cow sense anyway.)

ed··on Salesforce Pitched a 'Talent Acquisition' Contract to ICE
You’re playing apologist. Obviously, Benioff could have a set of actual, authentic values. Sadly he seems to point whichever way the wind is blowing.
ed··on Why I Chose Elixir Phoenix over Rails, Laravel, and Next.js
> He's also implying that Rails does not use web sockets to communicate with frontend which is not only wrong it should be evidently wrong to anyone who built a Rails app in the last 3 years.

I’m actually a rails dev but I’d reach for phoenix if my app required a large number of persistent sockets (e.g. high-volume MCP servers). I say this mostly because the hosting story is better for phoenix (gigalixir) than rails (heroku, or similar services that run behind a request router). Of course if you want your own infra this argument doesn’t apply. But a $100 gigalixir box can easily serve 100k persistent connections — even a few thousand persistent connections is a non-starter on Heroku.

ed··on After nine years of grinding, Replit found its market. Can it keep it?
A sustainable business can pay more employees than a failed startup. And pivoting with 150 employees is nearly impossible; all those people were hired for a different business.
ed··on Apps SDK
> Once a service can actively involve you and/or your LLM in ongoing interaction

Is there any progress on that front? That would unlock a lot of applications that aren't feasible at the moment.

Edit: Sampling is a piece of the puzzle https://modelcontextprotocol.io/specification/2025-03-26/cli...

I also see a lot of discussion on Github around agent to agent (a2a) capabilities. So it's a big use case, and seems obvious to the people involved with MCP.

ed··on Apps SDK
A bit underwhelming when you see what's actually on offer. "Apps" are really just MCP servers, with an extension to allow returning HTML.

A lot of the fundamental issues with MCP are still present: MCP is pretty single-player, users must "pull" content from the service, and the model of "enabling connections" is fairly unintuitive compared to "opening an app."

Ideally apps would have a dedicated entry point, be able to push content to users, and have some persistence in the UI. And really the primary interface should be HTML, not chat.

As such I think this current iteration will turn out a lot like GPT's.

ed··on Apps SDK
Anyone able to get this to work?

Lots of folks (myself included) are reporting it doesn't: https://github.com/openai/openai-apps-sdk-examples/issues/1

ed··on Y'all are over-complicating these AI-risk arguments
Nit: if you read the Wikipedia link it’s clear that guy has no claim to the high IQ record.

> It later transpired that Langan, among others, had taken the Mega Test more than once by using a pseudonym. His first test score, under the name of Langan, was 42 out of 48 and his second attempt, as Hart, was 47.[12] The Mega Test was designed only to be taken once.[14][15] Membership of the Mega Society was meant to be for those with scores of 43 and upwards.

ed··on Inflammation now predicts heart disease more strongly than cholesterol
It is, but as siblings note the evidence is real. You can purchase the test directly from Labcorp for $59 – https://www.ondemand.labcorp.com/lab-tests/inflammation-hs-c...
ed··on I forced myself to spend a week in Instagram instead of Xcode
It’s a kind of Pilates.

Sort of like Bikram for hot yoga.

ed··on Microsoft memo advises H1B employees to return immediately if currently abroad
The fee applies only to new applicants, per https://www.axios.com/2025/09/20/trump-h-1b-immigration-visa...
ed··on Show HN: Small Transfers – charge from 0.000001 USD per request for your SaaS
See also: Kachingle (2007), Amazon Flexible Payment Service (2007), Dwolla (2008), Tipjoy (2008), Facebook Credits (2009), Google Checkout (2006), Flattr (2010), Changetip (2014)
ed··on Show HN: Small Transfers – charge from 0.000001 USD per request for your SaaS
I mean this in the most constructive way possible: why do you think this idea hasn’t worked before, when it’s been fairly obvious and easy to build for a long time? And what’s your fix for that issue? You present the merchant side of things, but not the customer side which is more important to me, as a potential Small transfers adopter. What’s customer conversion like? Are micropayments actually better than typical payment amounts? Based on my experience I’d expect the conversion rate of a $0.01 and $1 fee to be pretty similar. The friction of inputting a credit card and trusting a service is way higher than the actual payment amount. I’d also have to introduce 2 more services to my customers: Small transfers powered by stripe, and customers would have to fund an account that realistically speaking can’t be used anywhere other than my site. Just offering some questions to think about!
ed··on Tesla offers mammoth $1T pay package to Musk, sets lofty targets
Insightful comment because this is the exact psychology that leads to bubbles!
ed··on Stripe Launches L1 Blockchain: Tempo
It’s a phrase used by sports commentators.

There’s a physicality in the definition that doesn’t really describe the best programmers I’ve worked with.

> In sports, "high motor" describes a player who consistently exerts maximum effort and intensity on every play, showing relentless energy, enthusiasm, and a refusal to take plays off, even when tired or the game situation is difficult.

ed··on Rose Scent Increases Brain Gray Matter
There is ~zero chance this is good science.

> 4.1. Limitation

> This study has three limitations. The first is the composition of the participants, that is, the participants in this study were only women.

> Relatedly, the study did not ask about the participants' lifestyle, exercise, diet, education, career, etc. These confounding factors may have influenced the brain and brain volume. Therefore, future studies should test for reproducibility when men are included and these confounding factors are controlled. The second concerns the intervention method.

> Although this study used a double-blind method, it is not that method in the original sense. This is because the participants in the experiment could easily guess that the liquid was just water from the smell they wore. Therefore, the reproducibility of the present research results should be verified by using liquids with some scent safe for the human body.

> Relatedly, this study used rose scent and no other scents. Therefore, while the results of this study indicate that rose is effective, they do not indicate that other scents are not effective.

> Participants were not monitored to see if they were wearing scent correctly. Therefore, variations in participants' adherence may have influenced the experimental results. Future research should monitor participants by requiring reports with photos etc.

ed··on Paracetamol disrupts early embryogenesis by cell cycle inhibition
Just NSAID’s - they’re anti-inflammatory and muscle synthesis happens in response to inflammation.
ed··on My First $500 MRR – My thoughts and learnings
My advice was actually the opposite. It's harder to take a new channel from 0-1 than it is to take an existing channel from 1-2. so in my experience it's better to double down on what's working. only branch out to new channels when you have the resources, or you've maxed out your existing channels. FWIW I don't think your channel is just SEO, it's also content marketing like this HN post. Keep it up!
ed··on My First $500 MRR – My thoughts and learnings
IME the competitiveness of results is probably a much bigger factor, considering exact-match domains are a very old SEO trick and Google doesn't reward them (it penalizes them, actually). "AEO" is a brand new concept so congrats on finding a new wave! Double down on SEO if that's working for you. It's hard enough finding 1 channel that works. The fact that you hit $500 MRR on the open web is actually pretty impressive, and you can likely scale significantly if you're aggressive about growth. Good luck!
ed··on The Drivers of HRM's Performance on Arc-AGI
TL;DR the “high” “low” level modules don’t matter much, and the rest of the architecture is similar to Universal Transformers https://arxiv.org/abs/1807.03819
ed··on GPT-5 for Developers
> There is a built-in login flow

Ah this doc needs to be updated: https://help.openai.com/en/articles/11096431-openai-codex-cl...

ed··on GPT-5 for Developers
I decided to check-in on Codex after being a longtime Claude Code user. The experience was not great. GPT5 is pretty solid, however!

- The permission system is broken (this is such an obvious one that I wonder if it's specific to GPT5 or my environment). If you tell Codex to ask permission before running commands, it can't ever write to files. It also runs some commands (e.g. `sed`) without asking. Once you skip sandbox mode, it's difficult to go back.

- You can't paste or attach images (helpful for design iteration)

- No built-in login flow so you have to mess with your shell config and export your OpenAI key to all terminal processes.

- Terminal width isn't respected. Model responses always wrap at some hard-coded value. Resizing the window doesn't correctly redraw the screen.

- Some keyboard shortcuts aren't supported, like option+delete to delete words (which I use often, apparently...)

This is on MacOS, iTerm2, Fish shell. I guess everyone uses Cursor or Windsurf?

ed··on The Loop Is Back: Why HRM Is the Most Exciting AI Architecture in Years
Skepticism warranted since ARC-AGI hasn't been reproduced and there's at least some debate about validation data leaking into the training set: https://github.com/sapientinc/HRM/issues/18

I'm eagerly awaiting reproduction. I hope the results hold up and someone finds a way to bolt language onto it.

ed··on Show HN: Host Claude Artifacts on your own domain
Just curious, what domain registrar do you use that also allows you to host static files?
ed··on Sleep all comes down to the mitochondria
Huh, you actually are an expert in this area. I’m curious to hear more too.

> There, I studied the early stages of neuronal development in the Drosophila embryo… > I graduated with my Ph.D. in September 2006 and decided that I would continue my research activity on sleep, using flies as the animal model.

https://lab.gilest.ro/giorgio

ed··on GLM-4.5: Reasoning, Coding, and Agentic Abililties
Subliminal learning happens when the teacher and student models share a common base model, which is unlikely to be the case here
← PreviousPage 2 of 23Next →