HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

diogenes-pithos

46 karma · joined December 7, 2022

submissionscomments
diogenes-pithos··on Instagram ads Facebook won't show you (2021)
How is the following not possible?

>Facebook disabled their account because of their ad content, but chose to put up a message that was more ambiguous.

diogenes-pithos··on Instagram ads Facebook won't show you (2021)
You're presupposing because you're coming to a conclusion that is not justified by the evidence.

The absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

> The only way it makes sense is

I don't think you've provided convincing evidence of that.

Are the following all not possible?

1. They are unable to access that account or page any longer

2. Facebook chose to lie about this in a way that is not easily disproved by a screenshot.

3. Facebook disabled their account because of their ad content, but chose to put up a message that was more ambiguous.

*edit: formatting & make messaging more polite

diogenes-pithos··on Instagram ads Facebook won't show you (2021)
They did speak out about it, which is in the same article linked above that sources the FB disputation statement (https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/06/facebook-and-signal-are-figh...):

> We absolutely did try to run these. The ads were rejected, and Facebook disabled our ad account. These are real screenshots, as Facebook should know.

I don't think your logic about companies lying really tracks with the historical record. Companies, when they believe they can get away with it, lie all the time.

Again, I'm not saying that one organization was certainly lying or not-lying; I'm just challenging your presupposition that Signal was lying.

diogenes-pithos··on Instagram ads Facebook won't show you (2021)
I think it'd be helpful for discussion to include Signal's dispute of Facebook's disputation of the story in your comment:

> We absolutely did try to run these. The ads were rejected, and Facebook disabled our ad account. These are real screenshots, as Facebook should know.

diogenes-pithos··on Instagram ads Facebook won't show you (2021)
Why do you believe Signal is lying about it, and Facebook is not?
diogenes-pithos··on Instagram ads Facebook won't show you (2021)
Why are you accepting Facebook's PR narrative as true?

From the article (https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/06/facebook-and-signal-are-figh...):

> Signal countered on Twitter that it “absolutely did” try to run the ads. “The ads were rejected, and Facebook disabled our ad account. These are real screenshots, as Facebook should know.”

I'm not saying Signal's side is necessarily true, but you're making an affirmative claim that Signal is performing a "misleading publicity stunt", by taking faith on Facebook's narrative as true.

*edit: posted the wrong link