HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

carmelo7

11 karma · joined March 14, 2011

submissionscomments
carmelo7··on Another Inside Job
Well, if you cite specific examples about what you're referring to that's from a factual and objective source (since there could be thousands of different viewpoints), I would know your premise. Simply calling a whole industry as engaging in deceptive practices as a common occurence -- and freely accepted among those in the industry -- is unfair, absolutely untrue, and does nothing to help the financial system become more effective for society at large.
carmelo7··on Another Inside Job
Please cite specific examples of common deceptive practices (not just anomolies) if you're claiming that Wall Street fully practices deception on a daily basis. To claim that they do so is just absurd. Taking a populist opinion without understanding specifically how the banking industry works, and what it can and can't legally do, just wreaks of the Dunning-Kruger effect.
carmelo7··on Another Inside Job
This is getting a little absurd. First, I'm specifically referring to the Feds in its tight control of the money supply during the Depression. They restricted the money supply. If you have another term for what the Feds did (note the difference between the Feds and the federal government), then so be it.

Loose monetary policy during a drought is not just supported by Keynesians (who really emphasize more expansionary fiscal policy), and is definitely not a 100% Keynesian view. Monetarists, for instance, support it widely. As do other economists. Friedman supported it, as does Bernanke, Greenspan, Summers, Mankiw, et al. To claim that an expansionary monetary policy is 100% Keynesian is just absurd and distorts the positions of other economists.

carmelo7··on Another Inside Job
That's absolutely untrue and intellectually dishonest. The Feds, as indicated by Friedman and Krugman, were tight with the money supply. Because money wasn't flowing, the economy wasn't running. Please go and read the causes for The Great Depression on any economist's website (or even Wikipedia).

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causes_of_the_Great_Depressio...

carmelo7··on Another Inside Job
Can you cite specific sources? I'd like to know specifically what you're referring to.
carmelo7··on Another Inside Job
That is absolutely untrue. Taxpayers do not pay for any FDIC insurance.
carmelo7··on Another Inside Job
The overwhelming cause for the Great Depression was tight monetary policy, and trying to let the market "sort it out" without providing any stimulus (e.g., QEs). When you have a highly illiquid economy with no spending or consumption, you get no growth; that factor prolonged the Depression. That conclusion is supported by economists across the aisle, from Paul Krugman to Milton Friedman, to everyone else in between -- including all living Nobel Laureates in Economics. That premise is the Fed's main justification for the recent QEs.