9,719 karma · joined August 16, 2011
And even trombonists have to learn how to handle sharps and flats in chromatic passages, so there's a lot more to transposing than using a different clef.
> Tenor clef shows up in modern musicals regularly.
This I didn't know, thanks!
In particular, trombones have almost entirely stopped using the tenor clef in jazz.
At least in western music you pick the seven basic notes on the scale, and that gives you the sharps and flats you place at the beginning of each line. That choice, from the point of view of notation, is even more important than the exact scale. And the choice is constrained to 15 sets of sharps and flats because it implicitly tells the player (veeeery roughly) to expect some patterns that probably will occur.
It doesn't always work great, for example if you want to write the Simpsons theme the set of notes in the scale doesn't fit any of those 15 sets. But it uses an unfamiliar scale in any case, so there's not much to gain and as a player you just deal with it.
See around 32:30 in https://youtu.be/Eq3bUFgEcb4?t=1950
Almost all sheet music that you play uses 5 or 7 unequal subdivisions of the octave, and occasionally the rest. Sure, sometimes you'll have one or two of the rest on a regular basis (blues, harmonic/melodic minor), but still most music won't use all twelve.
The parts that are really weird (like the C clef) have mostly been obsoleted, unless you play the viola I guess.
Interestingly, when reading Raymond Chen's article I thought "reservoir sampling would compare the random number (between 1 and n) to 1, not to n, because that extends more easily to picking more than one element" - and that's what the actual Windows code uses.
Harmonics and temperament aren't really relevant to all this, though at some point you have to explain why certain intervals are naturally consonant but "boring", and others can be made to make sense but mostly within a more complex voicing (which reconnects to topics like inversions and voice leading).
(For disclosure I studied piano until ~20, both classical and jazz, and I would call my knowledge of jazz theory "decent" for someone with zero professional or academic experience. Obviously not comparable to yours and not even in English, so perhaps what I wrote above will sound really stupid).
Scales and chords build the fundamental basic blocks for Western music (I would introduce equal temperament third but that's only a matter of ordering). They are taken for granted in musical practice, I agree, but only because musical practice concerns itself about how/what to play and why. If somebody comes from the point of view that clefs and stems (which are undoubtedly musical tools) are gatekeeping and all you need is a piano roll, this article explains from first principles enough musical building blocks to tell them why they're wrong.
The AI style gets boring very quickly, but I liked the explanation of what Western music notation is optimized for. For more information on this, there's a great and long video at https://youtu.be/Eq3bUFgEcb4.
(Edit: I wrote this around the same time as the reply, which more or less confirmed my hunch)
Intel by the way did the same for SGX, they called it xucode.
Here is the fix: https://lore.kernel.org/qemu-devel/20260826181552.848617-3-p...
In this case, of the four bugs it found:
* Two were in libslirp, which is not part of that subset; user mode networking these days should use passt (https://passt.top/), an insanely cool hack that does user mode networking at many Gb/s and is secure
* One (which had already been patched upstream) was in VGA emulation; it is borderline but I think it should indeed count as being part of the secure subset. On the other hand it wasn't usable in the configuration under test because it was correctly configured without a VGA.
* The VAPIC bug is letting a guest do things that it shouldn't do such as bypassing secure boot (and in this case facilitating the exploitation of a KVM bug), but is not a full guest-to-host escape and is not specific to QEMU being written in C.
So the real issue here was not QEMU but libslirp. And in this case it was KVM that turned out to have the worst bugs, not QEMU. Crossing fingers, the initial wave of AI-assisted security reports seems to have slowed down for KVM on x86.
The desktop environment you saw was nothing but the main virtual machine, and inside that was the green thread environment you describe. But the VMM on the outside was pretty solid.