HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

apersson

45 karma · joined November 5, 2010

@justposts
submissionscomments
apersson··on Goodbye, Chrome (How Chrome got me banned from hacker news)
It would be helpful to communicate something along the lines of "You're hitting our servers at an excessively high rate. Your IP has been blocked for x hours. Please take action to keep this from happening again."

You could also list possible benign causes (e.g. browser problems, naive crawling/scraping implementations).

This should reduce some confusion and save you some email.

apersson··on Goodbye, Chrome (How Chrome got me banned from hacker news)
Ok, a few replies:

1. Point on signal versus noise taken. A large part had to do with that I didn't have the time and skill to dive into problem more deeply (e.g. to get some sort of request trace from Chromium and file it as a bug). It was late, I should only post in the morning after sleeping on my posts.

2. Point on dev builds (and Chrome vs. Chromium) also taken. I realize it's one thing to use "trunk" on something that I use as a developer, where I engage with the software as a producer, and another to use it for software that I just want to work and not worry about it. I will switch my browsers to stable versions, since I'm a browser consumer, not developer.

3. Number of open tabs: During this incident, I had perhaps 40 to 50 tabs open, with around 10 to 15 hacker news pages.

4. Requests on restart were not the problem - I connected the browser to a dead proxy before restarting, and then went through the tabs stopping each one manually. Only after that did I reactivate my connection. My annoyance came from the fact that Chromium just started hammering away at pages "behind my back" so to speak, after I had manually told it to stop trying to connect.

5. Thanks for your recommendations on bookmarking alternatives.

6. I posted this here because hacker news was the only site that issued me a fairly explicit ban, and I wanted to help others with the same problem out. A few people responded that they've had the same/similar problems, so it wasn't a total waste.