HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

alistairSH

16,464 karma · joined November 19, 2012

Software Architect and Project Manager in Washington, DC area.
submissionscomments
alistairSH··on Self-Powered Trailers Promise Leaner Freight Runs
Uh, you still need suspension on the tow vehicle capable of the tongue weight. And enough mass that a gust of wind doesn’t push you over a lane.
alistairSH··on 42% of adults rely on their parents for financial support
Sure, totally get that, but we're talking about a cohort that is mostly retirement age themselves... How many of those 70-80 year old Boomers have parents left alive from whom to receive those retirement funds? That's why I'm hesitant to believe the number.
alistairSH··on 42% of adults rely on their parents for financial support
Source: https://news.northwesternmutual.com/planning-and-progress-st...

OK, now I'm questioning the whole thing... it also claims 17% of Boomers reliant on their parents. So, we have some substantial number of 62-80 years olds relying on their 90-100 year old parents? Seems unlikely.

alistairSH··on 42% of adults rely on their parents for financial support
33% of GenX is still depending on their parents? That's shocking... I'm at the young end of GenX at 49yo. So, a slice of the population that is fast approaching retirement age is still reliant on their septuagenarian or octogenarian parents for money? Wow.
alistairSH··on My midlife crisis Corolla is fast, furious, and modded
Have you driven a Miata? Even if the ZDX is objectively better in every way (which I doubt, but I could be wrong), I suspect the Miata will be subjectively better when rated for "is it fun to drive".
alistairSH··on SpaceX bond worth 10% less than issue price – heading for junk bond status
Except Russell did change their rules in 2026. Yes, in theory to more closely represent the state of the market.
alistairSH··on SpaceX bond worth 10% less than issue price – heading for junk bond status
Sure, and that's mostly ok. I earn more than many people, some people earn more than me.

The problem is that extreme wealth imbalance leads to a power imbalance that tends to throw society into turmoil. The French Revolution being a canonical example.

alistairSH··on SpaceX bond worth 10% less than issue price – heading for junk bond status
Then they should buy a broad-market fund.

Like a Russell 1000 fund? Oh wait...

alistairSH··on SpaceX bond worth 10% less than issue price – heading for junk bond status
Pretty sure Adam Smith captured that in his writings.

Full laissez-faire, free market capitalism generally leads to wealth (and power) imbalance. Regulation is necessary to prevent that (assuming you want to maintain a "fair" democracy of sorts and not regress to oligarchy).

alistairSH··on SpaceX bond worth 10% less than issue price – heading for junk bond status
"People" in this instance aren't always informed buyers. Sometimes they're buying an index fund because they don't have the time to research individual stocks and sometimes it's their pension investing.

The normal seasoning period is there for a reason. There is a massive downside to premature inclusion of a stock that is initially overvalued and then settles to a reasonable/sustainable value.

alistairSH··on US House of Representatives takes step to make daylight saving time permanent
Which was my point - 9-5 isn't really a thing, it's usually 8-5 or 9-6 or worse. If we're going to adjust time zone, we should at least agree on when most people are/are-not at the office/school/farm fields/etc.
alistairSH··on US House of Representatives takes step to make daylight saving time permanent
Pretty sure there are studies that indicate the time shift is actually harmful - more car accidents, more heart attacks, all sorts of things.

Really, the question is which system (standard, DST, or both) causes the least damage?

Also worth noting we tried permanent DST a few decades ago and it was repealed within a year because people didn't like it. Approval in advance was north of 70% and in the aftermath below 40%, IIRC.

alistairSH··on US House of Representatives takes step to make daylight saving time permanent
Does anybody actually work 9-5 (ie 7 hours assuming they take a break or two)?
alistairSH··on LAPD lets contract with surveillance giant Flock expire
https://www.ky3.com/2025/08/20/camden-county-presiding-commi...

This article seems to confirm what I stated above - he took the cameras, and was later confronted by law enforcement about it.

And even if your telling is correct, that's still theft. Similarly, I can't just take your car, drive it around, and call you later to tell you where it is.

alistairSH··on European "age verification" "app" forcing everyone to use Android or iOS
Yeah, that sounds like the ideal solution.

Unfortunately, we can't even get states to commit to our RealID requirements[1] (which doesn't even add a chip/PIN, it only strengthens validation of documents submitted at the time of application for a driving license). And the notion of a national ID is anathema to large swaths of the population.

1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/REAL_ID_Act

alistairSH··on What did SFFA vs. Harvard reveal about admissions?
Fair questions and criticisms.

I would prefer to have colleges [elite or otherwise] be generally representative of the population by race, religion, socio-economic background, etc.

The problem, as I understand it, is "best qualified" is massively impacted by things like race, parental income, and other factors outside the control of college applicants. Society is far from a meritocracy.

alistairSH··on What did SFFA vs. Harvard reveal about admissions?
You’re also deliberately ignoring the point that there might be no such thing as innocent third parties, but only people who aren’t aware they’re part of the problem, even if it’s subtle and unintended.

I was about to post the same and that's 100% my take... sure, I didn't own slaves and I don't intentionally do anything racist... but I can absolutely acknowledge that by virtue of genetic lottery (white, with educated parents, etc) I had it orders of magnitude easier than the kids who grew up on the other side of town (black, less educated parents, etc).

I said it in another comment - affirmative action may not be the best solution, but it's tiresome to see people trot out the "2 wrongs" argument without proffering a better solution to the problem.

alistairSH··on What did SFFA vs. Harvard reveal about admissions?
What data do you have to support the assertion that affirmative action is no longer necessary to ensure proper representation of minorities on campus?

I'm open to arguments that there are better ways to achieve the goal of equitable access to higher eduction, but looking at enrollment numbers, the problem is far from solved.

alistairSH··on European "age verification" "app" forcing everyone to use Android or iOS
I'm imagining something like recreation.gov in the US - it's the portal for booking campsites and other activities at national parks. It's run by BAH at great profit - most of the fees we pay aren't going to the national park service, it almost all goes to our corporate overlords.
alistairSH··on European "age verification" "app" forcing everyone to use Android or iOS
ID chip? Is that something everybody in the EU (or whatever region) has? Is it just embedded in your driver license or passport?

[I'm in the US, we're very ID-averse here, weird, but is what it is]

alistairSH··on European "age verification" "app" forcing everyone to use Android or iOS
You think most of the unsupervised internet time is happening at school? I mean, maybe it is, but that's an assertion I haven't seen before.
alistairSH··on The great digital fatigue: How digital burnout is changing social media use
Agreed. For me, "social media" is just any website/app that allows users to contribute content and make comments.

HN is absolutely "social media", as it Facebook and WhatsApp.

With that said, I do believe social media platforms exist on a spectrum of "mostly benign, maybe even useful" to "mostly harmful" with closed groups/forums well to the benign end, targeted subjects with heavy moderation somewhere to the benign end of the spectrum (HN falls here), and "free for all" well to the "harmful" end (this is where most of Meta lives).

alistairSH··on How to stop Claude from saying load-bearing
You're serious?

Operative, key, and critical are all more correct to me in this context.

alistairSH··on The great digital fatigue: How digital burnout is changing social media use
Even HN has a clout score, and seeing it move up/down, or slapping that up/down arrow, can trigger the same dopamine as social media by MegaCorp.
alistairSH··on How we can reduce traffic congestion
Removing parking minimums doesn't even prevent more parking - it only lets the market balance supply/demand for parking. The current system in most of the US requires worst-case/max-demand parking lots, so the only time a shopping center's lot is full is a few peak hours on the weekend and Christmas season. The rest of the year, it's mostly empty.

Here's a good summary of one case of a small town dealing with absurd parking regulations... https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017-11-22-how-parking-m...

And just to add my own recent anecdote... we visited southern Italy (Puglia) last month. Most of the towns have zero traffic* zones (ZTL zones) in the historic centers. In all of them, there were either ample metered street spots just outside the ZTL or small pay lots a short walk away. As far as I could tell, as a tourist, it worked well - the downtowns were vibrant with lots of foot traffic.

* ZTLs allow local traffic and handicapped transport within certain guidelines.

alistairSH··on LAPD lets contract with surveillance giant Flock expire
Except he did steal the cameras. He only returned them when confronted by law enforcement.

You don't get to rob a bank and then say "oopsie! my mistake, here's the bag of cash" when the police come knocking.

alistairSH··on LAPD lets contract with surveillance giant Flock expire
Sounds like his only recourse was to sue the county as a private citizen for failing to enforce their laws? Or something like that. Going vigilante, as much as I like it in this case, is still illegal.
alistairSH··on DOGE is done. What happened to its records?
This.

I live outside DC, lots of friends who are contractors in IT/software. More than a few have been on the same contract, doing the same work, for years or decades. It's effectively a full-time permanent position, or could be. Not sure how there's any efficiency there when the contracting firm's owners need to make a cut.

alistairSH··on How we can reduce traffic congestion
IMO, it's not so much "make driving worse" (ie actively make roads worse, etc).

Instead, it's actively make transit better be reallocating road funds... Add buses or light rail or dedicated/separated bike lanes instead of brainlessly adding traffic lanes. Every bike added to that bike lane is one less car (very roughly).

Additionally, tax car infrastructure appropriately. Free road-side parking is not an entitlement. Reduce parking minimums in redevelopment/new development and let the market determine the supply of spaces. A good example - it's increasingly common for apartments in DC to charge extra for a parking space.

Most of the above applies to urban areas as well as moderately dense suburban zones.

Large cities can take additional steps - no car zones (common in Italian towns), congestion pricing (London, NYC, and others already do this), and changes to road design to better accommodate pedestrians (plenty of YT videos about various plans to do this).

alistairSH··on Leak of San Francisco Police Drone Footage Exposes Reality of Urban Surveillance
Same as ALPRs and anything else related to policing.

We need protections/limits in place. But we also need a government that's reliable and "friendly" (to the extent a large government can be). We currently don't, so all these new techs are quite concerning.

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →