1,538 karma · joined February 22, 2016
I wonder if the 1m token context length is coming for this ride too?
Having more context, but leaving open an inability to effectively focus on the latest task is the real problem.
import this
Even on HN, indentation reigns king.When Claude can operate in the browser and effectively understand 5 radio buttons in a row, I think we'll have made real progress. So far, I've not seen that eval.
However. Price is king. Allowing me to flood the context window with my code base is great, but given that the price has substantially increased, it makes sense to better manage the context window into the current situation. The value I'm getting here flooding their context window is great for them, but short of evals that look into how effective Sonnet stays on track, it's not clear if the value actually exists here.
What eval is tracking that? It seems like it's potentially the most imporatnt metric for real-world software engineering and not one-shot vibe prayers.
In practice, it's very clear to me that the most important value in writing software with an LLM isn't it's ability to one-shot hard problems, but rather it's ability to effectively manage complex context. There are no good evals for this kind of problem, but that's what I'm keenly interested in understanding. Show me GPT-5 can move through 10 steps in a list of tasks without completely losing the objective by the end.
What are the reasonable local alternatives? 128 GB of ram, reasonably-newish-proc, 12 GB of vram? I'm okay waitign for my machine to burn away on LLM experiments I'm running, but I don't want to simply stop my work and wake up at 3 AM to start working again..
(And I should add, you are a hero for doing this work, only love in my comment, but still a demand for detail$!)
Simon claims, 'Grok 4 is competitively priced. It's $3/million for input tokens and $15/million for output tokens - the same price as Claude Sonnet 4.' This ignores the real price which skyrockets with thinking tokens.
This is a classic weird tesla-style pricing tactic at work. The price is not what it seems. The tokens it's burning to think are causing the cost of this model to be extremely high. Check this out: https://artificialanalysis.ai/models/grok-4/providers
Perhaps Grok 4 is the second most expensive and the most powerful model in the market right now...