758 karma · joined February 21, 2010
https://www.kellogg.northwestern.edu/faculty/gordon_b/files/...
I am not sure, what is different in your approach?
1. Too much noise, real strain to focus on each title. The reason why I say that the thumbnails as noise is because it is in no way helping me to decide whether to read an article or not. The only reason I choose an article to read is the title so anything else is mere distraction.
2. Due to the first reason,Skimming is not as easy as the original HN, which is important for all of us here.
But let this not discourage you in anyway. The good thing from what I can see from your work is, you know what you want and you know how to do it.
Thinking of an application based on this UI that you have designed might be browsing pictures in reddit.com/r/pics or imgur. Here the thumbnails of the image at the back will not be a noise, but a useful info to decide on whether to look at the picture or not.
And it should not be of any surprise in any kind of hub ,that even if collaboration does not happen abetment will happen. Purely because of the large presence of like minded people.
One good thought experiment would be to think of former hubs that have lost their culture. Thinking of that,I realize only hubs formed around matter (cities that sprang up around mines and oil wells) have been lost while those that rose on ideas will stay for a long time thriving with life,hope and innovation.
PS: I am a little surprised that PG notes that he meets so many techie people in his day to day life.
I believe he has no idea about War of Currents and who won it.
Even though I use FB more than any other social networking websites, I still think many of their features suck a lot (photo album, chat). It bothers me that they have been in business for so long , but they have failed to incorporate better features . For me the way FB was frantically responding to Google+ seems silly. They should have done these way before. Can anyone explain why FB had to wait for adding new features until Google+ was launched.