HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

accidentallfact

30 karma · joined June 29, 2025

submissionscomments
accidentallfact··on Do we just want slaves?
I said many, not everyone.
accidentallfact··on Do we just want slaves?
I think we are at the same stage as when 3D graphics began taking over. It was used everywhere, while it was clearly inferior to 2D graphics of the time.

The same problem is with AI today - it's clearly subpar to a competent human. It's just cheaper so it gets used instead, but that will probably change as AI improves.

Anyway, it seems to me that many people don't look for slaves in AI, but for their master, and primarily use AI to tell them what to do.

accidentallfact··on Giant trees have no trouble pumping water to top branches: new research
I don't get why it is believed that trees can't pump water above a certain limit, all it should take is a system of valves, something that plants already have for other purposes. It certainly isn't lumuted by trees literally sucking water up as that would limit them to a height that can be easily exceeded by the majority of trees.

It seems that trees just don't grow that tall anymore. Even common trees such as the spruce seem to be able to reach 100m, they just kind of don't.

One possibility is the depletion of nutrients. But what I think is to blame is the lack of elephants. They constantly ruined young trees and the lucky few that survived then grew huge. Perhaps the redwoods were actually created by the natives, who removed young trees, and kept the old trees standing.

accidentallfact··on The worthlessness of Vitamin D is mildly exaggerated
What if rickets is actually a variant of polio, and vitamin D is just a hormone, and not a vitamin?

Rickets still occurs in Africa with abundant sunlight, but with polio still present. (The strains that come from vaccines are usually not counted.)

accidentallfact··on India's surprise baby bust
>I’m going to try to win the award for the most controversial theory on this thread.

Extremely easy to beat that.

You can see that global population used to stay at around half a billion until around 1700. The growth is a recent thing.

So let me propose a more controversial theory - lead made people have a lot of children.

You can't beat this.

accidentallfact··on The dangerous delusion of modern warfare
Nothing of course. But he reportedly insisted that war with russia would lead to the rise of communism.
accidentallfact··on The dangerous delusion of modern warfare
Yes, the archduke who got assassinated just before the war started.
accidentallfact··on The dangerous delusion of modern warfare
From what I've read, Franz Ferdinand was the only one with any say in the matter, who could foresee the result of the war. So there is really nothing new about this.
accidentallfact··on Why is almost everyone right-handed? A new study connects it to bipedalism
Cetaceans are also strongly handed, sperm whales extremely so. It's possible it has to do with the brain size itself, perhaps it allows to save nutrients for one hemisphere.
accidentallfact··on Why senior developers fail to communicate their expertise
I'm going to get downvoted to hell for this, but you described the exact reason why education is a waste of time.
accidentallfact··on What have been the greatest intellectual achievements? (2017)
That, just isn't true. Many animals live in herds, flocks or other groups. There is a kind of fish that eats debris from the teeth of much bigger fishes. Predators get swarmed.
accidentallfact··on Working and Communicating with Japanese Engineers
I believe that this goes beyond vocabulary. It's more about who bears the burden in communication - in most cultures, it's the speaker, who is supposed to communicate clearly, and concisely. In western culture, it's the listener, who is expected to decipher whatever the speaker is talking about.
accidentallfact··on Sam Altman Is Losing His Grip on Humanity
He was talking about education. I'm pretty sure about it.
accidentallfact··on Pope tells priests to use their brains, not AI, to write homilies
There is no reason to doubt that Jesus lived in the Roman Empire, once you believe that he lived at all. And there is no reason whatsoever to doubt that the church formed in Rome. All known world was Rome at the time. From Britain to Morocco to the Middle East. (Islam only happened in the middle ages, it isn't that old.)
accidentallfact··on Pope tells priests to use their brains, not AI, to write homilies
It fell, (quite violently, in fact) in the third century. The rest was pretense.
accidentallfact··on Pope tells priests to use their brains, not AI, to write homilies
The thing that made him question geocentrism was that Venus quite visibly orbits the Sun.

It has always been known that the tides are caused by the Moon. The hard part is to predict the tides in detail, as they depend on the geography as well. Some of the first computers were invented to predict the tides.

accidentallfact··on Pope tells priests to use their brains, not AI, to write homilies
Napoleonic wars? The Spanish used guns against the Aztecs.

>The first use of firearms as primary offensive weapons came in the 1421 Battle of Kutná Hora.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_firearm

accidentallfact··on How far back in time can you understand English?
People always overestimate how 'phonetic' their language is, because nobody actually uses phonemes in regular speech. In Korean in particular, there doesn't even seem to be any obvious correspondence between what is written, and what is actually said.

Foreign accents don't come from any inherent inability to learn language after X years of age. They come from people pronouncing languages as they are written, and virtually no language is like that in reality.

accidentallfact··on Blue light filters don't work – controlling total luminance is a better bet
The amount of red light goes down, (and you can use a camera with white set to sunlight to check how much blue it gets on a clear day, it isn't an illusion at all) so if anything, we should be using red light filters, not blue.
accidentallfact··on Blue light filters don't work – controlling total luminance is a better bet
Even the premise of the idea is wrong, as evenings are either blue from the blue sky, or white from the clouds. It takes exceptional circumstances to have a reddish evening, and even then it's just around the sunset.

I guess that it may help people with undercorrected myopia due to the chromatic aberration, but, I don't know.

accidentallfact··on The Dark Side of the Enlightenment
I think the reason for it is actually pretty banal. Rationality won. But it didn't win over irrationality, but over superrationality, and we just suffer the horrors of its wrongness.
accidentallfact··on Where did all the starships go?
Too much of sci-fi has become reality, and space alone isn't interesting. So, you can fly to another planet? What are you going to do there? Talk with computers, like you do with your phone?
accidentallfact··on WiFi could become an invisible mass surveillance system
It applies to the sensor size as well. Such as you need a 3m sensor to get 100px per radian, under ideal circumstances, unless I'm mistaken. (I think I'm not)
accidentallfact··on The Singularity will occur on a Tuesday
It isn't a way around, you still obey. Only now, the authority you obey is a machine.
accidentallfact··on The Singularity will occur on a Tuesday
The point of Dune is that the worst danger are people who obey authority without questioning it.
accidentallfact··on The Singularity will occur on a Tuesday
A better approach is to make AI bullshit people on purpose.
accidentallfact··on The Singularity will occur on a Tuesday
Reality won't give a shit about what people believe.
accidentallfact··on Is particle physics dead, dying, or just hard?
I'm so sick of this "good guy approach". It didn't give us progress, it gave us those like Watt and Intel, highly celebrated bullshiters who stopped being relevant as soon as their IP deadlock expired.

I suppose the only solution is undeground science. Do enough progress in silence, dont disseminare the results, unless the superiority becomes so obvious that an armed resistance becomes unthinkable.

accidentallfact··on The time I didn't meet Jeffrey Epstein
The mechanisms in the body are not heat engines. The stuff is so tiny that it works basically by reshuffling molecules, so the traditional concept of efficiency doesn't really apply, as the amount of stuff that happens is given by integral math. You get this amount of charges from reshuffling this amount of molecules. The type of stuff that can be done is limited by how hard the stuff sticks together.

Anyway, the core problem of obese bodies is that they can't produce energy. You can't outwill it, the reshuffling just isn't happening, and there is actually no great reason to believe that fat tissue is some kind of fuel tank, rather than a mass of broken cells.

Also, the body can just reshuffle the molecules in an idle mode. You don't need to spend the energy on moving around.

accidentallfact··on The time I didn't meet Jeffrey Epstein
Thermodynamics doesn't apply to the body in any meaningful way. It sounds like a 19th century idea of how the body might work that people repeat with no understanding.

And, you not only need to get fuel from the food, but also the materials to build the engines, and for making spare parts and consumables. And everything that actually uses the energy. There will be no energy spent on lighting if you can't get the indium needed for making LED lights, and the body only knows how to make LED lights.

Page 1 of 3Next →