HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

abhay_agarwal

8 karma · joined March 18, 2014

submissionscomments
abhay_agarwal··on CoreOS and the the Future of the Internet
Container-friendly OSes are definitely the future. While CoreOS isn't the only one (Atomic, Photon, Snappy), there's very little need for most OS features that we traditionally expect in servers when lightweight containers wrap all our applications, and cluster schedulers manage failover.

As for load-balancing the problem, there actually is added complexity in new architectures because we add a layer of orchestration on top. However, that layer on top is becoming more and more necessary, so it makes sense to move a lot of functionality out of the OS layer.

If you want an example, think about how modern disk systems expect JBOD instead of RAID. When there is innovation on top, the underlying system can become simpler.

abhay_agarwal··on CoreOS (YC S13) Raises $12M to Bring Kubernetes to the Enterprise
To what scale? A lot of tools out there help you schedule containers, but to how many machines, containers, and level of resource utilization? Perhaps I meant that it's _technically_ an orchestration platform, but it's not at the level of quality that is required for large-scale orchestrations (i.e. Borg, Mesos).

And yes, as noted above I work for Mesosphere. YMMV.

abhay_agarwal··on CoreOS (YC S13) Raises $12M to Bring Kubernetes to the Enterprise
Kubernetes is not really a container orchestration platform. It helps organize containers into logical groups with dependencies, but orchestrating resources on your physical machines is well within Mesos' domain. Keep in mind that Kubernetes and Mesos aren't mutually exclusive. Kubernetes has been [implemented](https://github.com/mesosphere/kubernetes-mesos) on Mesos.

My opinion is that Kubernetes is closer in identity to Docker: tons of OSS excitement, many companies jumping on board, and really pluggable. As to whether its going to become the critical infrastructure piece that gets enterprise to pay $$$... that's a stretch.