HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

SmitheryB

8 karma · joined October 1, 2024

submissionscomments
SmitheryB··on Korean women remove pictures, videos from social media amid deepfake porn crisis
Photoshop has for decades been able to produce fake images indistinguishable from real life.

There's still no case for why fake video is apparently so much worse than fake images. Both achieve the same effects when sent maliciously to a relative or contacts list.

I'll (try to) steelman the case for why video's worse: because people don't realise how easy fake videos are to make. But in 1-2 years... meh... most of society will have it figured out.

SmitheryB··on Korean women remove pictures, videos from social media amid deepfake porn crisis
> an offending image couldn't be beamed to everyone you know instantly

Is your concern that recipients would think it's real? Or is it that people will get an email/chat message containing NSFW material? (because the latter happens now, and is nothing more than background noise at most). What is your actual, specific concern? (genuinely, I have no idea, but want to try to understand - to me it feels like panic about a problem that isn't actually a real problem).

SmitheryB··on Korean women remove pictures, videos from social media amid deepfake porn crisis
I feel as though I'm the only one who doesn't care about this.

Curious to know if 20-30 years ago, as graphic design tools got better, were people freaking out about being able to superimpose another person's face on a the body of p*rnstar?

Superimposing people's faces on to porn star's bodies happened/s, but does anyone care really even notice or care about it now days? For the most part, of course not.

So why should we care about porn videos? What makes them so different? The whole concern smells like typical media hype (i.e. yay - we get to write about AI + Porn - instant clickbait) that nobody will be able to stop and nobody will even care about in 1-2 years: e.g. "oh, yah, another deepfake of <(politician|actress|colleague^)> in a porn film - how incredibly creative".

^ Incidentally, this was made light of in the British version of The Office where a modified image of the boss, David Brent, was sent around the office. If it's joked about harmlessly on mainstream TV, it's probably not a huge concern.