HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Machow

9 karma · joined February 22, 2014

submissionscomments
Machow··on Why Is Academic Writing So Academic?
That's fair. For psychology methods it's easier to avoid both, at times, since you can write "participants viewed...", etc.. For other types of methods, especially where the object becomes implicitly understood, or would be redundant to state, I can see where passive voice might be useful. For instructions, you can just leave off the implicit "you should", EG "put X in Y". The tradeoff between passive and first person is important, and which is appropriate likely depends on the circumstance. They're both discouraged, but not banned, I'd imagine because poor writing often uses one or the other too often.
Machow··on Why Is Academic Writing So Academic?
For what it's worth, in Psychology (by APA standards) 1st person voice is discouraged, but so is passive voice. In the passages you use, removing 1st person (almost) requires using passive voice, but I would say removing 1st person voice is what discourages a very informal, prosey style, while the frequent use of passive voice often feels indirect.
Machow··on Common sense and statistics
I think the algorithm he is suggesting is..

1. Get empirical probability vote is within 2 million from previous N elections. (so, 1 if it is within 2 mill, and 0 of not, then average). Use it as p(vote is within 2 million). 2. Assume that if a vote is within 2 million, then the exact number of votes is uniform between 0 and 2 million. Then, the probability of a tie, given that the vote is within 2 million is p(vote within w million) / 2 million.

Machow··on Back to the Future: Slides Before PowerPoint
3D barcharts have a longer history than I thought!
Machow··on Winning A/B results were not translating into improved user acquisition
"given this measurement and our prior beliefs, the probability of page A being better than page B is X%"

FTFY ;). I think Bayesian methods add a lot of interpretive power, but I'm not sure that it would help people make a correct interpretation. I suspect that if practitioners are neglecting the difference between a one-sided and two-sided test, they will likely forget (or gloss over) what priors are (and their non-trivial implementation).

I definitely agree that their is a disconnect between the math and its interpretation, though.

Machow··on Packing things in your brain in a way that keeps them from leaking out
I really like the broad coverage that articles like this give to the psychology of learning, but I wonder how important some of these principles are in a practical sense. Sure, the effect of studying and retrieving in the same context is a classic effect, but how strong is it?

It's like reading an article on how to make money that doesn't even give you a ballpark estimate of how much money each strategy could make you.

Machow··on Statistical Advice for A/B Testing
Sorry if this sounds condescending. I'm asking out of total naivety. What is the background of people who typically run A/B tests? Are they often unfamiliar with things like multiple comparisons, stopping problems, and the like?
Machow··on Show HN: Learn to code by being coached by an experienced developer for free
I'm not talking about students who participate in experiments as subjects. The students who are research assistants are sometimes unpaid, and might not receive course credit for RA work, but contribute code to projects for research experience. It's relevant to working for a private, for-profit business in the sense that the alternative is often doing an internship for a private company.

The IRB only monitors study participants, not research assistant work.

Machow··on Show HN: Learn to code by being coached by an experienced developer for free
This seems to be exactly the case in psychology. Undergraduate students often assist with experiments in return for research experience on their resumes. Depending on the degree to which they were involved in a project, they may be thanked in a paper, but not listed as a coauthor.
Machow··on Quality of a man’s sperm depends on how intelligent he is, and vice versa (2008)
Agreed. That title made wonder what kind of crazy set of working memory training experiments took place. And I don't even know how they would test things in the other direction...
Machow··on How to Get a Job at Google
I was surprised by that, too. I work in a lab that studies intelligence, and IQ tests are generally designed to measure G (general cognitive ability). It's like saying, "we're interested in measuring height, and I'm not talking about inches".

I'd imagine he's saying that they want to assess general cognitive ability in ways traditional tests do not.