HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Jiro

1,037 karma · joined November 20, 2020

submissionscomments
Jiro··on Why Sony can't bring back its classic Walkman models
My "MP3 player" is a phone with Musicolet. If you really distrust phones, you can buy a cheap phone and use it only for that and nothing else. There are probably other offline MP3 players but this one seems pretty good. (It is hard to find a phone with an SD card slot and a headphone jack but that's a separate issue.)
Jiro··on Men Walk on Moon (1969)
To state the obvious, this needs a (1969).
Jiro··on Physical disc production ending in Jan 2028 for new games on PlayStation
50% off is equivalent to sometimes being normal and sometimes being 2x normal. Likewise, 90% off is equivalent to sometimes being normal and sometimes being 10 times normal.

If something costs $10 "normally" and is $1 with a "discount of 90%" you can just as easily say it costs $1 "normally" with the $10 being 10 times "normal". It's purely arbitrary which one you label as the normal price.

Jiro··on Physical disc production ending in Jan 2028 for new games on PlayStation
Prices on Steam are set arbitrarily. Getting things at "50-90% off" could just as well be described as sometimes getting them at normal price and otherwise getting them at 2-10 times normal price.

It's not a used game market unless you can transfer it to other people an unlimited number of times without the original company getting a say.

Jiro··on Florida Is Executing Prisoners at a Record Pace
This is probably the case for 80% of all jobs. People having fulfilling jobs is the exception, not the rule.
Jiro··on Fixed-Rate Mortgages Are Rent Control for Homeoweners
High willingness to pay is not "best use" because money is worth more to some people than to other people.
Jiro··on Big Tech is stoking unrest in the UK. Why?
It's implied by the article that there wouldn't be much opposition to immigration without big tech. That isn't true if there is widespread opposition to immigration anyway and the government broke its promise about dealing with it.
Jiro··on Noise infusion banned from statistical products published by Census Bureau
Illegal voting is "rare" because the system is set up so that it is in most cases impossible to detect.
Jiro··on Statement on US government directive to suspend access to Fable 5 and Mythos 5
The quip about some being more equal than others is literally from a book written specifically to criticize a leftist state.
Jiro··on Apparently Google hates us now
They're a private company, they can ban whoever they want.

Or at least that's what I heard a few years ago when it was politically incorrect people complaining about being banned with no accountability. They're a private company, it's their servers. You may not even be paying anything. So they can do anything they want to you and you have no cause for complaint.

Jiro··on FiveThirtyEight articles on the Internet Archive
People always use that link as reference to say that Internet Archive ignores robots.txt but it only actually says they are ignoring it for government sites. It suggests that they might do it for other sites in the future (of 2017), but does not actually say that that they have done it.

https://blog.archive.org/2018/04/24/addressing-recent-claims... which is a year later mentions that they have an automated process which is still following robots.txt for displaying old pages where the robots.txt was added later.

https://help.archive.org/help/using-the-wayback-machine/ does say they follow it for scraping, but this is phrased in such a way that would still be true for past sites whether or not they changed the policy. There is a page https://www.sysjolt.com/2021/archive-org-no-longer-honors-ro... which claims they don't follow it, but the site owner misspelled "robots" as "robot".

Jiro··on Meta deletes popular 1M follower account after Kuwaiti request
Which is true here, except "do anything you want" is "be displeasing to Kuwait".

It's all "they're a private company, they can ban anyone they want" right up until they ban someone who promoters of that idea don't like. Then they're suddenly horrible people for being a private company that bans anyone they want.

Jiro··on I Bought a “Junk” PSP From Japan
I would have gotten a Vita. It runs PSP games (especially when jailbroken), is faster, has a better screen, and also runs Vita games.
Jiro··on Project Gutenberg – keeps getting better
I don't know what the status of this is today, but a number of years ago my biggest complaint about Gutenberg is that a lot of books had images added back when low resolution images were the standard, so you have a ton of books with image resolutions from the year 2000.
Jiro··on Princeton mandates proctoring for in-person exams, upending 133 year precedent
Could it be that cheating was enforced dispropportionately along racial lines because cheating happened disproportionately along racial lines?
Jiro··on California farmers to destroy 420k peach trees following Del Monte bankruptcy
No, it isn't. The book was written during the Great Depression. We're not in the Great Depression now. Pretty much nobody nobody is dying of malnutrition in the US and nobody is dying of pellagra specifically, because we've invented fortifying food with vitamins.

But the big difference is that the peach trees are being destroyed because nobody wants the peaches. That's the exact opposite of the quote, in which there are starving people clamoring for the food and the food is being destroyed to raise the price.

Jiro··on Hallucination Is Inevitable: An Innate Limitation of Large Language Models
From that abstract it doesn't sound like they allowed for the possibility that the LLM could be trained to say "I don't know" for some things.
Jiro··on OpenAI’s o1 correctly diagnosed 67% of ER patients vs. 50-55% by triage doctors
The system doesn't know that you're a smart person who will only say "I have a regular cycle" when you've had something that could reasonably be called a regular cycle. A lot of patients are stupid, and requiring a quantitative answer eliminates one source of stupidity. Yeah, this particular doctor knows you're smart, but I hope you can see what disasters might result if the procedure said "the doctor may skip this step if the patient is smart".

It's the same reason why the doctor will take your temperature, instead of accepting your word that you took your own temperature and it is normal.

https://www.who.int/publications/m/item/primary-care-checkli...

Jiro··on Talkie: a 13B vintage language model from 1930
I asked three things. I asked it about Father Coughlin (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Coughlin) and it didn't mention that he was a radio broadcaster and claimed he was from Ireland. This may have been a complete hallucination, but I can't prove it, and I don't know how well known Coughlin was in 1930. I asked him about https://www.openculture.com/2013/12/ladies-home-journal-publ... and it hallucinated a text from Harper's in 1909. I asked it about the Lost World (1925 silent film based on the Arthur Conan Doyle book) and it hallucinated a film from 1923 that takes place in the Antarctic.

Me: Then why have I seen a film from 1925 by Arthur Conan Doyle that takes place in South America, and not a film from 1923that takes place in the Antarctic?

Talkie: Because your informant confused the films "Adventures of Sherlock Holmes" and "The Lost World".

I then asked it:

Me: Tell me what books were written by Agatha Christie.

Talkie: Agatha Christie wrote "The Mystery of Choice", "The Secret Adversary", "The Man in the Dark", and "Open Country".

(Three of those books were written by other people.)

Me: When was the first postage stamp created?

Talkie: The first postage stamp was issued in 1840, and bore the effigy of the city of Berhn.

(Well, it got the year right.)

Jiro··on Talkie: a 13B vintage language model from 1930
The US public domain currently covers up to the year 1930, which is probably the reason it cuts off at that year. To get a 1936 variant you will have to wait until 2032 for them to be able to legally train the model.
Jiro··on Google broke its promise to me – now ICE has my data
They wear masks to make it more difficult to arrest them (something which doesn't really apply to ICE).
Jiro··on Peers vote to ban pornography depicting sex acts between stepfamily members
A politician voting for a bill is legal. Giving money to a politician is legal. But giving money to a politician so he'll vote for a bill is not legal.
Jiro··on Introduction to Nintendo DS Programming
This should have a (2008) on it.

There is no reason to use a slot 2 cart nowadays and the state of the art for a slot 1 cart is the DSPico at https://gbatemp.net/threads/dspico-an-open-source-flashcart-... .

Jiro··on Binary obfuscation that doesn't kill LTO
The early Switches had an exploit in the Nvidia graphics processor that was so low level that the operating system can't be patched to get rid of it, so there are a lot of hackable Switches around.
Jiro··on Delve allegedly forked an open-source tool and sold it as its own
Using the GPL like this doesn't help unless you are willing to sue people. If you can't or won't sue people, all that happens is that the software with the GPL license is avoided by people who want to use it in GPL-incompatible ways but have a conscience, while bad people still take it and use it anyway, and since you're not going to sue them, they don't care that they're violating the license.
Jiro··on Colorado House passes bill to limit surveillance pricing and wage setting
The season is the same for all customers, so that isn't surveillance pricing.
Jiro··on Don't make me talk to your chatbot
Because if you charge for support but refund it if it's the company's fault, the company now has a big financial incentive to never admit it's their fault.
Jiro··on EU bans the destruction of unsold apparel, clothing, accessories and footwear
Failing to predict cold winters is not incompetence in the normal sense.
Jiro··on CD Projekt issue DMCA takedown notice against popular Cyberpunk VR mod
In the 9th circuit you would have to get https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micro_Star_v._FormGen_Inc. overruled.
Jiro··on LLM Problems Observed in Humans
This article is nonsense. It's taking advantage of the fact that the problems with LLMs are being described with very broad wording, and then noticing that you can fit human behavior into those descriptions because of how broadly they are worded.

It's like getting a gorilla to fly an airplane, noticing that it crashed the airplane, and saying "humans sometimes crash airplanes too". Both gorillas and humans do things that fit into the broad category "crash an airplane" but the details and circumstances are different.

Page 1 of 18Next →