HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Grieving

226 karma · joined March 23, 2021

code monkey, contrarian
submissionscomments
Grieving··on Pirating GPL Software
This whole fight is bizarre. Elementary people requested that the author rename his project to avoid confusion in a way that could be interpreted either as friendly or a veiled legal threat. The author was immediately combative, and didn't calm down after multiple clarifications that they were not looking for a fight, legal or otherwise. He responded by doxxing them, and is now attempting to "expose" them for this.
Grieving··on GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘whistleblowing’ website
IIRC they've said they have no problem kicking people off for ideological reasons, and that the name has more to do with pricing than anything.
Grieving··on To catch a paedophile, you only need to look at their hands (2017)
There are few other crimes so heinous and with such a high recidivism rate as sexual abuse of children. Attempting to reforming such people appears to be a fool's errand (and that's leaving aside that retributive justice is a real and necessary component of a serious society).

I know the usual response is that not all pedophiles are going to actually carry out their fantasies, but really we have no evidence that "non-offending MAPs" or "virtuous pedophiles" (or whatever they call themselves) are a real or significant phenomenon; plenty of those who have claimed these titles have been exposed as abusers.

Grieving··on Does this medieval fresco show a hallucinogenic mushroom in the Garden of Eden?
> not the other way around

That's highly debatable. See The Germanization of Early Medieval Christianity[1] for a good, detailed counterexample. The reformation and counter-reformation have been likened to a re-Judaization of Christianity with good reason. Based on my reading, though, the pagan roots of Christianity run much deeper; for example, the concept of three gods, separate yet one, is completely alien to Judaism, but integral to Indo-European religion. It's not found in the Bible, but was made use of to explain the relationship between the three divinities found in the New Testament.

1. https://www.amazon.com/Germanization-Early-Medieval-Christia...

edit: I misunderstood you. The statement I thought I was responding to was that christianity absorbed pagan practices but not beliefs.

Grieving··on Mozilla: *Privacy Not Included
> sites get downgraded if they don't require strong passwords

Assuming "strong", as usual, means uses upper+lower letters, numbers, symbols, etc., this directly contradicts NIST's current password recommendations. They recommend enforcing a minimum length instead, and recommend a "minimum minimum" of 8. They also recommend checking passwords against a set of the most common ones from leaks. The NCSC's top 100k list is good (pre-filtering those under your minimum helps too--only 47k remain after removing pws under 8 chars): https://github.com/danielmiessler/SecLists/blob/master/Passw...

Grieving··on So you want to self-publish books and courses on programming
This is what pragprog does, but I don't know any self-publishing platform that does the same. You can probably roll your own without much trouble, just using stripe for billing.
Grieving··on Court orders US Capitol rioter to unlock his laptop ‘with his face’
I'm curious, would it be a violation if they instead invoked the Fifth Amendment to protect other contents of the laptop not acknowledged to exist?
Grieving··on Don’t Apologize: If the mob comes for you, stand up for yourself
They are absolutely not complaining about private citizens lambasting them online. It's entrenched monopolies in cooperation with the state itself that work to ruin right-wing (and left-wing in the case of TERFs, Deep Greens, etc.) dissidents' lives and deny their ability to speak. For instance, banks are closing their accounts for opposing the status quo. Banking is so strictly regulated, incestuous, and intertwined with the state that innovation is notoriously difficult; and innovation from an explicitly adversarial entity with no institutional support is nearly impossible.

What's more, if one lives in a red state surrounded by people similar to them on the political spectrum, they'll still have their employers harassed to keep them from holding down a job. It's not their peers "cancelling" them; it's a minority of people with wildly different worldviews from wildly different parts of the country. It's not all that different from swatting.

Grieving··on The incel lexicon: Deciphering the emergent cryptolect of a global community
Why is operating outside of the paradigm of liberal feminism automatically equivalent to vilifying women? There seems to be an insatiable need for liberalism to 'other' those outside of it: critical of feminism? Misogynist. Critical of CRT? Racist. No need for discussion, no need to examine the internal contradictions of the worldview.

It's not unfounded, but MRAs are purely reactionary; they're the mirror twin of their enemies. They replace the "patriarchy" with the "gynocracy" and call it a day. I prefer authentic harmony between femininity and masculinity, but neither of these movements serves this purpose at all (some will object that they do, but both view their opposite as inherently poisonous--within feminism men can only be "good" by "betraying masculinity", and vice versa).

Grieving··on Multiple local news stations say the same thing verbatim [video]
I used to work for a local newspaper that had been operated by the owner's family for generations. Our content was almost entirely unique, with the exception of a few filler stories we'd occasionally pull from another source (small stuff like "Spring Cleaning Tips"). The owner was proud that we were the last small newspaper in the state to resist being bought up by the owner of the capitol city's paper. We were well-respected in the area, and it was joked that the only time we lost a subscriber was when they passed away. The owner died a few years ago. Her sons didn't want to keep her "hobby project" afloat, so the paper finally was sold like all the others.

A couple of years later I wrote a script to consolidate stories from news sites across my state and display them with a nice UI, since I have family all over the place and want to keep up with what's going on. The majority of stories were duplicated across all of them, and local news had become the filler content. Even for stories of national importance, they can be interpreted in so many ways that you'd expect different people in different areas to have different analyses of the facts (which is what used to happen), but that doesn't exist anymore. With the pushback against "fake news", official news sources are the only acceptable source of information, and those are monopolized by an increasingly tiny minority of people. BTW I don't put "fake news" in quotes to say that it doesn't exist, but that it's a catch-all term for propaganda that goes against the official propaganda.

Grieving··on Supreme Court affirms tribal police authority over non-Indians
I misspoke when I said the US, I meant the people of the US (i.e. the nation, not the state).
Grieving··on What the Aztecs can teach us about happiness and the good life (2016)
Depends on what you think is best in life https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oo9buo9Mtos

edit: looks like I was beaten

Grieving··on Supreme Court affirms tribal police authority over non-Indians
Kind of, but there's only one nation called America. You can't separate native-ness from nation-ness. If the US called itself something else, then there would be no Native Americans.
Grieving··on Supreme Court affirms tribal police authority over non-Indians
One absurd name vs. another. "Indian" is the result of a mistake by an outsider, which probably isn't that unusual if one goes digging into the names for various ethnic groups. "Native American" feels artificial, but more importantly isn't accurate either. The native Americans would be the descendants of the American colonists, the founding people of a nation; not those who were conquered by these people. The people we call Native Americans might better be described as aboriginal, or as in Canada "first nations".
Grieving··on Supreme Court affirms tribal police authority over non-Indians
The article is a little confusing to me.

> Now, with this latest ruling, the court has clarified that tribal police can search non-Indians suspected of state or federal crimes in Indian country and detain them until handing them off to federal or state authorities.

Non-Indians who commit crime on the reservation I grew up around are already searched and detained by tribal police until state police arrive. Crimes there do not go unpunished. The article claims this is a new policy, but a look at the syllabus seems to indicate that it's just an affirmation of existing policies that were being challenged in this case.

> As a “general proposition,” the “inherent sovereign powers of an Indian tribe do not extend to the activities of nonmembers of the tribe.” Montana v. United States, 450 U.S. 544, 565. The Court identified in Montana two exceptions to that general rule, the second of which fits almost like a glove here: A tribe retains inherent authority over the conduct of non-Indians on the reservation “when that conduct threatens or has some direct effect on . . . the health or welfare of the tribe.” Id., at 566. The conclusion that Saylor’s actions here fall within Montana’s second exception is consistent with the Court’s prior Montana cases. See Strate v. A–1 Contractors, 520 U.S. 438, 456 n. 11; see also Atkinson Trading Co. v. Shirley, 532 U.S. 645, 651. Similarly, the Court has held that when the “jurisdiction to try and punish an offender rests outside the tribe, tribal officers may exercise their power to detain the offender and transport him to the proper authorities.” Duro v. Reina, 495 U.S. 676, 697. Ancillary to the authority to transport a non-Indian suspect is the authority to search that individual prior to transport, as several state courts and other federal courts have held. While that authority has sometimes been traced to a tribe’s right to exclude non-Indians, tribes “have inherent sovereignty independent of th[e] authority arising from their power to exclude,” Brendale v. Confederated Tribes and Bands of Yakima Nation, 492 U.S. 408, 425 (plurality opinion), and here Montana’s second exception recognizes that inherent authority. In addition, recognizing a tribal officer’s authority to investigate potential violations of state or federal laws that apply to non-Indians whether outside a reservation or on a public right-of-way within the reservation protects public safety without implicating the concerns about applying tribal laws to non-Indians noted in the Court’s prior cases. Finally, the Court doubts the workability of the Ninth Circuit’s standards, which would require tribal officers first to determine whether a suspect is non-Indian and, if so, to temporarily detain a non-Indian only for “apparent” legal violations. 919 F.3d 1135, 1142. The first requirement produces an incentive to lie. The second requirement introduces a new standard into search and seizure law and creates a problem of interpretation that will arise frequently given the prevalence of non-Indians in Indian reservations. Pp. 3–7.

Grieving··on Daily Mail Published Nude Photos of Katie Hill. Now She Has to Pay Them $100k
Human instincts are amoral. You can't blame people for having a feeling, only for not properly moderating it.

> The results of the current study suggest that all individuals, not just highly sexually prejudiced individuals, may experience a physiological response indicative of stress when witnessing a male same-sex couple kissing.

https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/19419899.2017.13...

Grieving··on Daily Mail Published Nude Photos of Katie Hill. Now She Has to Pay Them $100k
I don't disagree in general but

> publishing extremely personal and private nude photographs of you without your permission for all the world to see

The photos were originally published by Hill and her husband for all the world to see.

> a tiny tattoo of a run of the mill iron cross on her hip

Given that ordinary citizens lose their jobs for the OK symbol and other such innocuous things, it feels like a throwback to another time to hear the phrase "run of the mill iron cross".

> homophobia, as the “shock” factor comes in part from her being naked with another woman.

I don't think so. Straight people, particularly men, have a strong physiological reaction to male homosexuality that doesn't really exist with female homosexuality. There's even evidence that the latter has historically been strongly selected for as a socially acceptable outlet for female sexuality (it "didn't count" as losing one's virginity or cheating). Hence it was often tolerated in countries that strongly prohibited male homosexuality (i.e. Nazi Germany), and when not tolerated was less fervently repressed. It would have been more shocking if the photos were of her and a male staffer.

Grieving··on This FSF form assumes everyone's full legal name can be written in ASCII (2011)
There's always a tradeoff between autonomy and practicality. Do we need to implement drawing for all "text" inputs (and outputs) so that people like Prince won't have any issues expressing their autonomy with something like this? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prince_(musician)#/media/File:...

(I'm aware that this was a stage name, but it is a legal name in the US)

Grieving··on Sixth grader expelled after Zoom provided possibly inaccurate IP address
The kid is being accused of rape and mass murder threats, which seems like something the school should take seriously (although it does appear there may be serious issues with the evidence). They don't want him back there, but expulsion itself is strongly discouraged due to the "school-to-prison pipeline", so schools do weird things like this instead.
Grieving··on Autism is a “disorder” only because the world is neurotypical
I agree. I was diagnosed with high-functioning autism when I was younger, and assumed that autism referred to people fairly similar to me.

Then my daughter was born. She's extremely low-functioning with only basic non-verbal communication (pulling me to the door means "let's go outside"; pulling me to the kitchen means "I'm hungry"). We've done PECS boards, AAC devices, ASL, etc, and she'll use them occasionally but they frustrate her. She has almost no instinct of self-preservation and a fascination with water, so will eagerly jump into a body of water if she has the chance; likewise when we go for a walk she doesn't understand that she can't just run out into traffic. Screaming and self-injury are constant and extreme.

Which is to say that I don't think she and I have the same condition. Maybe there's a common genetic basis, but her quality of life is unimaginably worse. I get annoyed often by the 'disability advocates' who more resemble me and want to speak for people like her.

Grieving··on My experience with sexual harassment in the Scala community
>Not prosecuted != not provable

Fair enough. Only 4% are known to be provable.

>Not provable != false

I neither claimed nor implied this. My point could be summed up as not provable != true.

Grieving··on My experience with sexual harassment in the Scala community
>2-8% of rape complaints are false

Complaints is the key here. Obviously, we can't say much about the incidents that don't go reported. If one looks at the conviction rate for rape complaints it's around 2%. So if we take the lower estimate for false complaints, it still means that only 4% of cases are provable one way or the other, and that those which are have a 50/50 chance of being true or false complaints. (I'm looking at '92 stats, at a glance it appears the the rates for both rape and false rape convictions have risen a fair bit since then).

Interestingly, a 2% conviction rate is on par with that of robbery.

https://blogs.findlaw.com/blotter/2017/07/how-often-do-rape-...

Grieving··on [dead]
The James Fields case isn't nearly as cut-and-dry as they pretend. There's video of his car being attacked immediately before the accident, a confession by a Redneck Revolt (antifa) leader that he chased Fields' car with a gun, and then Fields' tearful breakdown when he heard that someone had died. Not long ago liberals laughed at the absurdity of not running over violent rioters.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=08Khc2wqtCQ

Grieving··on _hyperscript: A jQuery and JavaScript Alternative
I really like hyperscript et al. They seem to apply the 'everything-in-one-place' approach from modern JS development to HTML itself, extending hypertext without papering over it.
Grieving··on Black Girls Code
I don't know if this is true everywhere, but my objection is mainly that there are no similar but unrestricted programs at all here. It's one thing to make a program tailored to girls when there's already one tailored to boys, or one that's not but happens to appeal mainly to boys. It's another thing entirely when the only options are girls-only.

> white, male, middle class, suburbs, nuclear family, single income, etc

You have next to nothing in common with a poor, rural white male with a single mother, so why shut them out based on your own privilege? Since poverty is already seen as a proxy for race, why not just start programs in poor areas without explicit focus on race? It has the same general effect without shutting the door on other underprivileged people.

Grieving··on Black Girls Code
That's true. I didn't expect something that would be perfect, but this was basically someone's list of steps to make a webapp with bootstrap, pagination, slugs, and a single CRUD resource.

If you're going to start with web dev, better to teach teach plain HTML and CSS, and enough JS to make something small happen, then let them run with it and help them customize it. Something like an in-browser alarm clock would be interesting. Show them how to change the font, colors, sound, background image (maybe even a background slideshow), and some animations.

Grieving··on Black Girls Code
Despite my extreme objections to the race/gender preference, I enjoy teaching and accepted the invitation to help out at a program like this (not this one in particular). I didn't get the idea that they were highly effective. Sessions consisted of walking them through an insanely long list of terminal commands and code snippets that were to be copied without any real understanding of what was happening. By the end the girls just looked overwhelmed and discouraged at the amount of garbage needed to create a "modern web app", which is certainly the most stupid place to start with programming. I left feeling as though I'd thoroughly destroyed what interest they may have had in the field, and never accepted another invitation.
Grieving··on Heroin-Using Professor Wants to Change How We Think About Drugs
Can't read with the paywall, and this is probably contrary to the message of the article, but this interview (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H6ZFzEW7_Q4) with a homeless heroin adict made a great impression on me. He comes off as both extremely self-aware and honest.
Grieving··on FBI arrest man over alleged Amazon centre bomb plot
Should the FBI be actively grooming all susceptible people for terrorism? This does not bode well for the the mentally ill, intellectually disabled, and children.
Grieving··on Establishing Twitter's Presence in Africa
If that growing middle class becomes dependent on westerners for employment, they will become westernized. Colonization can be extremely 'peaceful'.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →