HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DaveMebs

448 karma · joined December 12, 2010

submissionscomments
DaveMebs··on From the IE Team: Google Bypassing User Privacy Settings
This is a totally disingenuous comment. From the linked PDF (note: this also occurs on page 7, not page 6, for those who wish to verify):

"We discovered that Microsoft’s support website recommends the use of invalid CPs as a work-around for a problem in IE. Specifically, a FRAMESET or parent window that references another site inside a FRAME considers the referenced site as a third-party, even if it is first-party content located on the same server [10]. Microsoft suggests the following invalid CP: CAO PSA OUR. This CP is clearly invalid since it does not contain any RETENTION or CATEGORIES tokens. Even if the CP were valid, Microsoft’s recommendation undermines the purpose of P3P since it encourages web administrators to use CPs that do not represent their actual data practices. We found several technical blogs recommending similar solutions [11], [19]."

So yes, a Microsoft support site did recommend a set of invalid CPs, but this is clearly not the same trick. This is a legitimate set of CP tokens that is used to workaround an issue where 1st party content appears to IE as 3rd party content. This token set is invalid because RETENTION/CATEGORIES tokens are missing, but the web author's intent here is (theoretically) honest.

Google, on the other hand, is providing no tokens whatsoever. Instead, in their P3P header they provide a human-readable string and a link to their privacy policy. This is not an invalid but intellectually honest set of tokens that is designed to comply with the spirit of the standard, if not the letter. This is an attempt to bypass the standard in order to allow 3rd party cookies, regardless of user settings.

The fact that you are equating these two practices is completely dishonest. Even a cursory glance through this document makes it clear that the Microsoft support site is advocating something completely different and is doing so in order to enable a fairly legitimate scenario.

DaveMebs··on Craig Silverstein, Google Employee #1, Leaving for Khan Academy
Education credentials (especially college degrees) represent the ability to apply yourself towards, and accomplish, a stated goal over the course of multiple years.
DaveMebs··on Neil Young is right — piracy is the new radio
KEXP pretty much fits the bill. http://www.kexp.org/
DaveMebs··on Doing Y Combinator a second time
The thing is, it's not just a grid with some cells that does some math. Excel is incredibly powerful and if you integrate it with the full Office Suite + Sharepoint, you can really start to do some amazing things. I'm constantly blown away with the tips and tricks I learn from people at work.

I recognize that most startups aren't going for the full MS package (esp. Sharepoint), but I look at these tools as a suite that grows in power as you need it. With the Ribbon, you get great discoverability of these advanced functions as your needs arise.

DaveMebs··on Dear Comcast, I'm leaving you because...
Have you checked out Clearwire? http://www.clearwire.com/

They've got great coverage throughout Seattle and I have been very happy with their home internet plan. $50/month for unlimited data with 6mbps down and 1mbps up.

DaveMebs··on Windows drops to No. 3 cash-cow status in Microsoft' latest quarter
VS Express is a free, fully featured IDE. What Pro/Ultimate features would really attract a new set of Windows developers? By the time you need Ultimate features, you can probably afford Ultimate.
DaveMebs··on Microsoft confirms UEFI fears, locks down ARM devices
According to the article, "For non-ARM systems, Microsoft requires that Custom Mode be enabled." It seems incredibly likely that OEMs will "go out of their way to provide a different model with a differently implemented UEFI."

I'd imagine it does matter which architecture was being discussed.

DaveMebs··on The Economist on Intel versus ARM
The next release of Windows will run on ARM. This is a key point in the article.
DaveMebs··on Letter from Orwell to his publisher regarding 1984
Updike? Fowles? Asimov? McCarthy?

Obviously listing a bunch of names isn't going to prove the argument one way or the other, but I think it's a bit unfair to claim that all post-WWII literature is crap mod a few exceptions. Sci-Fi basically didn't exist before 1940.

I think it is more relevant to look at the 19th century vs. 20th century.

DaveMebs··on Letter from Orwell to his publisher regarding 1984
I don't think you can really compare the last 50 years (anything more recent and it's really hard to judge how 'great' an author will be) with a 150 year period. Especially when you are including the Lost Generation which was, frankly, contemporary in 1945. Hemingway hadn't even published "The Old Man and the Sea" at that point.
DaveMebs··on Why Don’t Smartphones Have A “Guest Mode”?
I think the concerns are the interactions between user accounts. I don't think anyone is too worried about the hidden root account having access to your user account data.
DaveMebs··on Google demotes Chrome in search results over pay-for-post promo
The thing is, this just doesn't matter. They still have a Chrome ad at the top of every page and if people are looking to find Chrome it's already simple. The outgoing links don't matter, because the sites the Chrome page links to are also easy to find.
DaveMebs··on Louis C.K. experiment results: over $500,000 in 4 days
When you go to the purchase screen you can choose between "contact me," and "don't contact me." To Louis' credit the default is "don't contact me," but I as a fan actually opted in to receive future notifications. I fully expect to be notified next time this opportunity arises (and I am probably not alone).
DaveMebs··on Louis C.K. experiment results: over $500,000 in 4 days
I don't think there is any evidence to support the notion that "a lot of people purchased this only to support the experiment." Sure, some folks on a HN thread commented to this effect, but I think that the vast majority of the 111000+ people who bought this probably like Louis CK. I recognize that I don't have any data to support my assertion either, but given the options of "buy this because I like Louis CK" and "buy this because I like alternative distribution models," I am fairly confident that more people are on the side of the former.

I also don't know why you think most of his "true fan base" would have bought this already. I love Louis CK and only found out about this because I am an HN reader. Why would you think most non-HN readers even know this is available? I mean really, I think you should at least wait a week before decreeing that "today's most most popular working comedian makes less money selling independently."

DaveMebs··on Microsoft can remove apps and data from Windows 8 devices
Maybe not for you, but I'm willing to bet "same as Apple and Google" does cut it for Mom.

(Note: I'm talking about the figurative mom, not your biological mother.)

DaveMebs··on ARM launches free toolkit for Android
"DS-5 CE completes the serious app developer toolkit with a comprehensive C, C++ and Assembly"

I think it's fair to say they expect most people to be writing C/C++, not Assembly.

DaveMebs··on MPAA Costs Hollywood More Than US BitTorrent Piracy
It doesn't matter how much the MPAA costs in relation to current levels of BitTorrent traffic. The comparison you need to make is the cost of the MPAA vs. the amount of money Hollywood made from Netflix. From the MPAA's perspective, if there was unfettered piracy and no making/enforcement of the laws, everyone would pirate their content. Thus, the MPAA is protecting the $180 billion that Hollywood made off Netflix because those customers did not steal.

Now obviously lawsuits and lobbying drive some customers to choose Netflix over BitTorrent, but there's also the fact that Netflix and BitTorrent deliver completely different online movie services. Netflix serves customers a limited selection of movies that they can start watching right now. BitTorrent delivers "customers" any movie they want, but they need to wait before they can start watching it the first time. They can watch it right away any time after that, even if they aren't on the internet, however. The author assumes that, cost aside, Netflix provides a superior offering. That might be true, but if both were legal, I know what I would choose (and it's not Netflix).

DaveMebs··on In defense of the Google chef
No, we are not really talking about unvested shares to be earned in the future. We're talking about unvested shares. These are shares that employees have already been paid. This payment is contingent upon the employee continuing to work at the company. Zynga is in effect blackmailing these employees. They are telling them "Give us this money we promised you, or we'll fire you."

The idea behind putting together a plan to keep early employees highly motivated is that you all work hard to grow the company, and in return for the risk and hard work you stand to make a lot of money. That's the whole idea behind tech startups. To grow the company and then tell these employees they don't get the rewards promised them the entire time they have worked there is ridiculous. It violates the entire idea behind vesting shares, which if it is unclear, is that you have already earned those shares. It's merely a matter of when you gain access to them.

DaveMebs··on Real Security in Mac OS X Requires Apple-Signed Certificates
What? Your first paragraph concludes that if everyone is checking Verisign's CRL they become the single point of failure for half the internet, yet you conclude the a better solution is to only check Apple's certs, making them the ONLY point of failure? I don't think you really understand how digital certificates work.

Downloading blacklists of certs is exactly what happens. They are called OCSPs and CRLs. The operating system is responsible for tracking these through a combination of caching and downloading new OCSPs/CRLs. The database does not grow too large, because CAs use certificate chains. The cert that is vouching for some website is not the cert in your trusted root store. Root store certs are kept under lock and key - these very rarely get compromised (this is what happened to DigiNotar and they are no longer in business - their certs were invalidated by everyone in the industry and they were filing bankruptcy less than a month later).

What does happen are leaf certs being compromised. When this occurs only that leaf and everything below it in the chain is revoked, so if you have enough certs in the chain you usually don't revoke many certs at a time. Generally speaking, the lower the cert in the chain the lower the trust level, which includes stuff like the cert not remaining valid for as long a period.

You can read about how Windows implements cert revocation here: http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ee619754%28WS.10%...

I'd assume Apple does something very similar.

DaveMebs··on Your number one priority
CA is amazing for everything described above, and doable from the SV, but it is muchless convenient than I imagine Vancouver Island is. Living in Seattle I can be actively engaged in any of the above with a 45 minute drive or less. From the SV, you are likely looking at a trip to Tahoe for any good climbing, hiking or skiing. It's doable, just not as convenient. (Note: I hate to appeal to authority, but I lived outside Sac for 4 years and Seattle the last year, and it is definitely easier here.)
DaveMebs··on Redditor burnt by Paypal's "Rolling Reserve" feature
No, the article makes it clear that PayPal is not a licensed bank in the state of Illinois and this behavior is presumably illegal. The author claims to have filed a complaint with the state's attorney general.
DaveMebs··on Redditor burnt by Paypal's "Rolling Reserve" feature
I think there are a few key points that highlight why offsetting risk is not a valid justification for this behavior:

-A 30% default rate is absurdly high. There is no way 30% of the cards being used over the phone are stolen.

-Even if usage of the service stops, the Rolling Reserves are a permanent change to they way PayPal handles his account. He cannot turn this off, even if his risk profile goes to 0.

-PayPal is not even authorized to act as a bank in the state he lives and operates in.

DaveMebs··on Turn Your Smartphone Into A Robot
This was my first thought as well. I built a similar robot in terms of physical design and motorized capabilities a couple years ago for ~$400. It wasn't controlled by a phone, which will admittedly adds some complexity, but I really can't see their overall hardware costs, including prototypes, getting into the 10's of thousands. Is the expectation here that this is also covering a living wage for the developers? It seems like they would be more successful with a lower funding request with the plan being to make a profit once the device hits market.

EDIT: It looks like they aren't even applying a solder mask to the board, which is a really cheap way to improve quality and reliability. For an extensible product that they want people hacking, I'd be spending the few dollars to help minimize short circuits. From my experience, everyone who has skimped and not gotten a solder mask applied to their board ends up regretting it down the line.

DaveMebs··on Time-zone database used by Unix shut down due to IP litigation
You really think short-long-short-short-long is better? It seems confusing enough to be of dubious value. Why not have seasons and months be equivalent and each equal to 73 days in length? That way you'd had the 50th day of summer, for example. Sure it would require a new season, but you reduce complexity quite a bit and there is no reason to keep the existing 12 month requirement. You can align the first month/season with the first of the year and add a 0-day for leap years.

Yeah, it's kind of fun to think about...

DaveMebs··on Google’s Management Doesn’t Use Google+
Yeah, 'cause it's not like the current CEO has tied every employee's bonus to Google's success in social, regardless of whether or not they work on the product...

Oh, wait.

http://www.businessinsider.com/larry-page-just-tied-employee...

DaveMebs··on Microsoft Explains Why the Start Menu Needed to Die
They are looking at the change in usage, not the total usage. Your complaints would be more apt if they were just looking at data for a single release, rather than a trend across releases. If users are switching to another method, regardless of what it is, you can argue that this is a failing of the Start menu.
DaveMebs··on Microsoft Explains Why the Start Menu Needed to Die
I don't know about the overall upgrade pricing for OSX, but if you wanted to go from 10.4 to 10.6, they required you to buy the full suite with iLife and all for $129 or whatever it was. $30 upgrades are only supported if you upgrade every time.
DaveMebs··on The Patent Pledge
Corporations are legally required to act in the best interest of their shareholders. If something benefits the company at the expense of humanity, they are required to act against the best interests of humanity.
DaveMebs··on Windows 8 on a laptop: first look
If you activate the Search Charm from the new Start page you are presented with an alphabetical listing of all installed application (Metro and Desktop).
DaveMebs··on Windows 8 on a laptop: first look
Space bar also works.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →