HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

DataDive

283 karma · joined March 4, 2024

submissionscomments
DataDive··on Asking authors about their own papers
What keeps someone from generating this video with AI?
DataDive··on Why do we need human mathematicians anymore?
Chimanzee vs Human is not an appropriate analogy. First, because they cannot communicate properly.

A better analogy: look at all these highly trained engineers, mathematicians, doctors, writers, philosophers, writers, scientists.

How many dumbass politicians do we need to keep it all running smoothly?

Turns out no matter how dumb politicians were, overall society has been developing positively over the history of mankind.

DataDive··on Neovim have a ~$800k Bitcoin donation sitting untouched since 2023
What happens if some of those tax the unrealized gains bills pass in some country where they have obligations?

They would have to either pay the tax on gains or write off losses.

DataDive··on Europe's summer drought is so extreme that desertification is a growing threat
Note that this 10% is heavily skewed toward the richest, biggest cities.

In bigger cities, it might be closer to 20-30% of their economy.

Take that away, and it would have a cascading effect through entire countries.

DataDive··on Europe's summer drought is so extreme that desertification is a growing threat
Europe is caught in a dilemma: tourism, air travel, and city hopping are its economic lifeblood that keeps the continent running, but these also cause the greatest damage to the environment.

Since they can't fix the real problem are trying to go "green" in counterproductive ways that make things worse: blowing up nuclear plants or taxing cow fart.

DataDive··on Emacs vs. Vim 2026: 24.3% vs. 8% Usage, 20x Memory Gap
Or perhaps AI code generation will "kill" both editors.

Why bother learning any editor when you do not need to write code, and there is no reason to enter

gg=G``zz

DataDive··on Iceland votes on whether to restart talks on joining EU
Ok, but why is it the Icelandic crown "bad"? What is the economic cause of it?

I do not know much about Iceland, only that, like New Zealand (and Canada), it is sometimes painted as some sort of progressive heaven that the US should aspire to.

Then, as you learn more, it turns out life isn't that great there.

DataDive··on Iceland votes on whether to restart talks on joining EU
Why wouldn't the price also fluctuate if it is in Euros?

Doesn't the price fluctuation reflect an economic reality?

Related: couldn't a country adopt euros voluntarily without joining the EU? Like Ecuador adopted US dollars.

DataDive··on Gemini Omni 1.1 Flash
Before AI, cool and interesting shots carried the promise that it was reality - even if it was perhaps exaggerated.

The amazing videos and photos carried the promise that I could experience that for real. They were aspirational.

Today I suspect every cool shot is made of pixels arranged on a 2D screen by an algorithm. It doesn't do it for me.

That makes me sad...

DataDive··on MIT's Ad Hoc Committee on AI Use in Teaching, Learning, and Research Training
Isn't that how Parasite starts?
DataDive··on MIT's Ad Hoc Committee on AI Use in Teaching, Learning, and Research Training
This seems to have touched a nerve, based on the number of downvotes.

In this particular case that makes the message more trustworthy for me ;-)

DataDive··on U.S. State Department pauses immigrant visa applications
You misunderstood my reply completely.

I am saying we are not selecting for those people.

When we hire at the university, we ignore creative, tenacious people and instead select mediocre people with a nice woke story that meets the woke requirements.

DataDive··on U.S. State Department pauses immigrant visa applications
Or as the saying goes: nothing is more permanent than a temporary solution.
DataDive··on More than half of adults in U.S. say they lack basic statistical understanding
LOL, 62%? that seems low ...

I would say the overwhelming majority of even university faculty members lack a basic understanding of statistics.

In their heads, they’re doing something closer to informal Bayesian reasoning: they have prior beliefs based past observation, previous research, experience, etc., wich is then all baked into every choice and decision

But when it comes time to write the paper, they translate that into frequentist statistics: p-values. As if all should be compared to random chance: significance thresholds, confidence intervals.

They do this to give their conclusions formal credibility: oh look how compelling my result is, I found all this new surprising stuff.

Close to 100% of life sciences research works that way.

DataDive··on Universal health coverage could save $1T and 114k lives a year: study
I think people should not use the word nazi so liberally if they want to be taken seriously; it's not that complicated either ...
DataDive··on Universal health coverage could save $1T and 114k lives a year: study
The point he is making is valid: these groups are not randomly selected and are not representative of one another. Hence, it is not that simple to extrapolate from one to the other.

Would free healthcare reduce deaths in uranium miners that are smokers? Probably some, but would it bring that to the same levels as non-smoking, non miners? Unlikely so. Hence it would be silly to pretend all the cancer deaths are due to lack of health care.

The smoking uranium miner example has a surprisingly realistic story, comes from real data; the dangers of radon in the basement were deduced from comparing cancer rates in smoking uranium miners with high radon in their basements, then they removed what they thought was the smoking and uranium contribution, then fitted to the general population.

DataDive··on Universal health coverage could save $1T and 114k lives a year: study
I did not know who that person was, but you seem to be saying none of his opinions could possibly be right?
DataDive··on Incident with Github.com
Maybe they should charge a little more per action, and the onslaught would stop.

Seems like a simple solution.

DataDive··on Malicious skills targeting Claude Code and Moltbot users
Great monologue, shaky biology.

Viruses do not multiply endlessly. Most viruses exist in stable ecological cycles.

Most viruses are beneficial to life. We complain about the few (and tiny minority of viruses) that infect humans and we do so from a selfish perspective, but forget about all the other that make life and evolution possible.

As a matter of fact evolution favors reduced lethality in many cases because wiping out hosts is bad for viral survival.

Agent Smith is way off on this one ...

DataDive··on US trade deficit widens by the most in nearly 34 years in November
None of these products would be made in the US, though ... and none would affect trade imbalance ... so the net effect might only be to increase inefficiency in your own country
DataDive··on Honey has now lost 4M Chrome users after shady tactics were revealed
I had the opposite reaction ... they still have 16 million users ...
DataDive··on Why is it so hard to buy things that work well? (2022)
Reply: things don't work well for the same reason this very post is so hard to read wall of text.

I find it deeply ironic that the author can't even produce readable text, while complaining about other, much more complex tasks not working.

The author refuses to take minimal, common-sense measures to make the text more readable.

DataDive··on "Begin disabling installed extensions still using Manifest V2 in Chrome stable"
> Hopefully this is the inflection point for Chrome.

Here is one empirical data point.

I switched over to Firefox this morning and will advocate for it.

I've considered it for a while, but I never felt motivated to make the switch. It took me a good half hour to set it up the way I like it.

DataDive··on On the Nature of Time
Without even visiting the page I can predict what this writing will be about with uncanny accuracy.

1. Big words at the start - pretending to hack at a problem so big that just swinging the axe is a major undertaking

2. The prose slowly drifts to make less and less sense; words have no practical meaning anymore.

3. Simplistic images galore. Various plots via cellular automata and "pretty" images show things that have nothing to do with the topic and are only distant metaphors at best. Yet these images are the proof that it all "works."

4. A nothingburger by the end. Leaves you wondering, why did I read all this?

Every essay by Wolfram is the same.

DataDive··on Filed: WP Engine Inc. v Automattic Inc. and Matthew Charles Mullenweg [pdf]
There is a parable that applies here,

---

The donkey, feeling unappreciated, approaches God with a heavy heart.

"Dear God," says the donkey, "why is it that all the other animals mock me, belittle me, and hold me in contempt?"

God listens patiently and replies, "My dear donkey, I understand your pain, but there's nothing I can do."

Surprised, the donkey responds, "But you are God! The all-powerful, creator of all things. Surely you can help?"

God smiles gently and says, "I may have created the world, but even I cannot change public opinion."

---

Matt Mullenweg might feel like God and might be among the most influential and richest people on the planet. But they won't be able to change public opinion, which is without a doubt against them.

I would advise stopping the madness before it is too late.

DataDive··on Filed: WP Engine Inc. v Automattic Inc. and Matthew Charles Mullenweg [pdf]
That's what going "nuclear" looks like ... I guess Mullenweg found out.

Sadly, instead of supporting open source with $5 million, they each will spend 10 million on lawyers.

DataDive··on Tim Peters – Dispelling Information Asymmetry
Another writeup:

The Shameful Defenestration of Tim

https://chrismcdonough.substack.com/p/the-shameful-defenestr...

DataDive··on DOJ accuses Visa of monopoly that affects price of 'nearly everything’
Excellent point made here; credit card balance can be a money maker, actually! The actual opposite of debt.
DataDive··on DOJ accuses Visa of monopoly that affects price of 'nearly everything’
I am not calling others wrong, I am calling the definition incorrect.

A credit card balance during the grace period is not a debt - it is no different than paying by check - it is not more than a delay between a purchase being reflected on an account. That's all.

Only the balance after the grace period should be counted as a debt if we are using that term to talk about a population being more or less indebted than say X number of years ago etc.

A credit card balance is simply a form of bank account for large number of people.

DataDive··on Europe's deadly floods are glimpse of future climate
Statements like the above are what should give everyone pause.

I think that statement can't be true.

Detailed measurements exists for less than a hundred years - yet the WWA is cock sure this is the highest rainfall ever. It goes to the credibility.

Page 1 of 5Next →