HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

Alyan

57 karma · joined February 1, 2017

submissionscomments
Alyan··on Was Rust Worth It?
Async in traits feature doesn’t use boxing (which is coming in 28 December), only async-trait crate use boxing.
Alyan··on Saudi Arabia Allows Women to Travel Without a Male Guardian's Permission
Why is that even a good idea at all? First most of these laws are a result of the culture here and if a vote were to happen are likely to remain or at least be controversial. Even the silly driving ban which have no religious basis is/was controversial even amongst women. Enforcing non popular laws from a foreign entity is a good recipe for disaster and may increase resistance to these laws and start wars or other bad stuff. Heck I think most Saudi citizens, even the liberal ones, would not want such actions.

In addition, I think they are also too many countries which doesn’t match US ideals, will US start WW3? For example there are many islamic countries with differing laws but I would guess most don’t match US ideals.

Alyan··on Saudi Arabia Allows Women to Travel Without a Male Guardian's Permission
It seems that as I suspected requiring consent for leaving prison or abuse shelter was also abolished.

https://twitter.com/dralmuneef/status/1157139494765645826?s=...

Alyan··on Saudi Arabia Allows Women to Travel Without a Male Guardian's Permission
I think it is a conservative/religious issue mostly. Women are harmed from this so it may be easier for them to change their opinions. However many women hold the same view and are not happy with such changes. The marriage without consent could be possible because there is one sunni maddhap which allow this. (For example in Egypt I think)

My views maybe inaccurate and in general I am pessimistic. However many are not happy with what the current government is doing and any change which may seem clearly against Islam could be the straw that break the camel’s back.

I would like to add that the criticism is lower and maybe in kinder tone due to the low freedom speech ceiling so it is actually hard to gauge the general opinion of current changes in this article.

Almost no body I know talked about this, perhaps many are unhappy with it or afraid of society judgement for supporting such changes.

Alyan··on Saudi Arabia Allows Women to Travel Without a Male Guardian's Permission
I would like to add, quoting from times:

“Other changes issued in the decrees allow women to register a marriage, divorce or child’s birth and to be issued official family documents”

IANAL but I am a Saudi citizen and it seems male consent to leave prison and abuse shelter may be included in these changes. I have seen Saudi citizens speculate about both possibilities so it is not clear yet.

Only one of the four major Islamic Sunni madhhaps allow females to marry without consent. Saudi Arabia follows a different madhhap. So if I were to speculate I don’t think it will happen soon because it may risk a revolt as I believe most citizens are religious or at least conservative. However, I also did not expect the current changes to happen this soon for the same reasons so I may be wrong.