Can you point to any more info about Caltech's honor system? I haven't heard of it before and you piqued my curiosity. (Couldn't find much on Google.)
Can you point to any more info about Caltech's honor system? I haven't heard of it before and you piqued my curiosity. (Couldn't find much on Google.)
Exams are not proctored. They are usually take home. It is up to the student to honor the rules of the test, such as time constraints and whether it is open or closed book.
This has interesting results. It turns the students and professors into collaborators rather than adversaries, it's simply a much nicer atmosphere.
It's so easy to cheat that there's no status for it. In fact, if you're going to cheat, you'd better be damn sure your fellow students don't find out about it, because they'll ostracize you. The students like the honor system, and they're not going to tolerate anyone undermining it.
Also, students often simply left their dorm rooms open. In my four years there, I never heard of any incidents of students stealing. Not once. It was pretty obvious that the students simply would not tolerate other students stealing. Policy was that the campus security was not allowed in the dorms unless invited by the students.
I hope that gives some idea of how it worked.
Just to emphasize how pervasive this is among the community: I have had several locked bikes stolen from Pasadena City College which is just blocks away, while at Caltech I left my bike unlocked every day for six months without a single incident.
Regarding the exams, the professors (and I believe TAs as well) are straight up forbidden from being near the students during any exams and the result is one of the lowest rates of cheating across all surveys.
The vast majority (if not all) of the classes I sat in on very much encouraged collaboration between students (even on exams in some aerospace classes) and the only request from professors was that each student write the names of their collaborators on each problem set.
Absolutely incredible culture that shows how treating someone as a responsible adult can reinforce mature and honest behavior.
The neat thing is I've applied these ideas in my subsequent life, and by and large it's been very successful. People tend to rise to your expectations of them. For example, I refused to put copy protection on the software I sold in the 80's, and never had any problems with piracy.
I also run the D programming language forums, and the D Conference (along with Andrei). We refuse to put a code of conduct on either. We simply assume professional behavior, and that's what happens.
[x] It was also really weird. People would steal your bike to ride across campus (it was very rural), then someone else would probably bring it back a week later.