Hacker News Reader

Comment by bhousel | Hacker News Reader

What he wants is basically what Palm is giving him, except for one point..

The device won't install apps directly off the developer's website - it will only install apps either through the actual app catalog, or through a free link that somehow goes through Palm. However they said that they would provide these links for any app, even without any formal review process. Really, this is a good thing.

Why? Because Palm needs to be able to yank an app if it turns out to be malicious. They are doing this to protect their platform, and it's a reasonable security measure.

View on HN

That's ridiculous.

Why should I let Palm decide what I can install on my phone? Android, Windows Mobile and PalmOS users have been doing fine with having the option of installing their own software.

You still can install whatever you want on the phone. You just need to jump through a few (very minor) hoops to enable developer mode.

The Palm Pre has a thriving homebrew community of hackers who have done exactly this, and have written over 250 apps that don't go through the standard Palm app store and can be installed just by a normal download link.

See: http://www.precentral.net/homebrew-apps

Palm devs have even been following the homebrew community closely and invited many of the developers there to offer their apps through the official app store as well as through the homebrew scene.

In this same world where Apple and Palm babysit phone owners does Dell get to dictate what software I install on my netbook and get to ban certain pieces of software because they're not approved by them? I understand the idea of vendor lock in and I don't think it's in Palm's worst interests to try to profit from their App Catalog but trying to justify it based on safety just sounds absurd.

I don't see any reason why palm couldn't still disable evil apps no matter where they came from.

What if the evil app removes their capability to do so?

If the app was on the device from the web or from a store it could remove their capability, but if the app is not yet on the device palm can easily upload a list of bad apps to not allow to run. Presumably this is what they would have to do with an existing app store app that went bad as a way to kill the one that have already been installed.

What if the list on my phone is out of date?

Then how would having bought it through the store done anything?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com