Why does the precursor "as a rule..." change anything?

I have not increased the drama at all. Someone posted a totally hyperbolic statement. I called them on it. It was upvoted numerous times I suspect because a consensus agrees with me.

It is not intelligent to tear down popular things because they are popular. You could have very well removed Gladwell and added Apple, Microsoft or French wine.

I haven't yelled, have I?

Your protip is baffling. Who is apparently smart? The OP? How have you reached that conclusion? By the possession of a HN account?