Hacker News Reader

Comment by astrodust | Hacker News Reader

The HipChat native client for OS X has been fantastic, plus there's an iOS client that pairs well with it, giving you push notifications for mentions.

It's not clear if Slack has this too.

View on HN

Slack has nice native clients for OS X, Android and iOS too.

I wouldn't call the OS X client "native". Sure, it's an app, but it's just a wrapper around the web page.

True, but it has dock badges, native Notification Center notifications and keyboard shortcuts for navigating chat. That's close enough to native for me.

I'm still holding out to see if they add Linux and Windows client support. Until then, HipChat is the only option for us.

Why's that? I use Chrome Application Shortcuts for Slack and it essentially creates a task bar shortcut, and works with desktop notifications. It's currently missing background notifications, but aside from that, there's no appreciable differences between it and something truly "native client".

Chrome on Linux is barely usable most of the time. But having something that is native lets you do all the fun things you can do with native apps: auto-start at login, minimize to systray, alt-tab with nice icon, and so on.

Maybe Slack is different, but most rich web apps I've used ends up eating gobs of memory after prolonged usage.

OS X client appears to be wrapped HTML rather than native.

I wouldn't call Hipchat's OS X client native; it's Flash (Adobe Air). The Slack's desktop OS X and iOS apps, while they are html based, are an order of magnitude nicer to use.

no it's not. their new OSX client is native. the old version is Adobe Air.

Their new windows client (and therefore I imagine the others too) appears to be Qt and Webkit. Most of it still seems to be their web app wrapped in native...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com