Hacker News Reader

Well, the vacuum tubes have already been replaced. (I do agree with you though)

Wrong again, not in the music scene. A lot of people still prefer amps made out of vacuum tubes, because they feel the sound is more human, has more texture, and is more smooth.

Whether it's correct or not is not the point, but proves the point TylerE was making: This is an emotional thing. And some will make the point of theatre and cinema, but there's still theatre and theatre has never really been as interactive as a music concert / DJ on the deck anyway.

For a PA system? I'm pretty sure all of that is using transistors now.

For a guitar amp, I hear you (though I also think the quality of things like guitar rig in the last few years have started to sound pretty believable)

I meant both. I've talked to guitarists/electronics engineers who design amps for their guitars, but they're still in use, I think. If my memory serves me well, Marshall still uses them.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com