Hacker News Reader

Question for the women: does the use of non-gendered pronouns do anything to make you feel more accepted by the programming community?

It seems to me like there are much bigger issues to worry about, and changing some docs here and there is nothing more than feel-good measures (along the lines of "we must do something, this is something, therefore we must do this" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politician's_syllogism)

But I'm not a woman so I have no idea.

View on HN

My girlfriend, not a programmer per say but has done a some technical documentation in her time, says that non-gendered pronouns doesn't make her feel more accepted but gendered pronouns do make her feel less accepted.

I find both "he" and "she" jarring. When there's no reason to use gender, it shouldn't be used.

It makes me think the author either 1.) does not have a strong enough command of the english language to use "they", or 2.) is trying to accomplish something by picking a gender explicitly.

That's well put, and I'm with you, but let's also note that the language norm is in the process of shifting, so it isn't necessarily obvious.

I specifically had multiple women both on my Twitter timeline and in private communications tell me how alienated they feel by gendered language, and this reaction to fixing it in general.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com