I think the biggest problem or criticism with these deals is that they are being negotiated with special interests completely in the dark.
When it then comes up for public voting (in senate, congress, whatever) any attempt to amend or change it is turned down with the justification that "the deal has already been agreed upon by our international parties", parties which needless to say will be given the very same explanation when they too object.
This is special interests trying to frame something as an "agreement" which everyone somehow sees a benefit from, while it most certainly is not.
This sort of thing needs and deserves as little secrecy as possible, so that we can avoid long-term, fundamental damage to the internet. Serving these dinosaurs one last dish isn't worth much, and definitely not a price that big.