You do realize he (allegedly) paid to have someone killed, right?
Prohibition also created a significant amount of violence... which has all but mysteriously disappeared. I wonder why. Did people magically become less evil? I think not. I think a fundamental flaw in the system was addressed properly back then, and certain perverse incentives were eliminated.
Eliminate the illegality and you eliminate the incentive for "hits" to prevent jail time or extortion.
> More consenting adults being arrested for consenting.
The "consenting adults" argument is tough to make when hits are being put out.
Eliminate the illegality and you eliminate the incentive for "hits" to prevent jail time or extortion.