I would have never guessed that it would, either. I was pretty shocked to see it here when I loaded up HN on my phone.
When I was inviting friends to be a part of this, there was a big divide... half of them LOVED the idea and felt like an island was something special (as I do), and others just saw it as some difficult-to-access land. I've had a tough time articulating exactly why an island seems special to me.