The second photo that we later realized we had was one a teammate had taken himself and didn't have anyone else in it. I think it was doable with just 1 photo, and I'm not ready to share with Justin how the 2nd photo helped. :)
OK then, there is something identifying about this girl, which the second photo gave you
* Tattoo
* Glasses
* Hair
* Amputee
* Scar/burn, etc.
* particular purse/hat/watch/accessory
* etc.
A credit card slip with her name on it perhaps?