People are very unlikely to buy more books because they're cheaper. Yes probably one out of ten people will buy more books, however the majority won't. I don't buy a book because it's priced $9.99 I buy it because of the Author, like most readers do. In fact I bought my wife a book last week that cost $9.95, why? Because I'd been recommended the author, price had nothing to do with the purchase.
Why was the book I bought $9.95 brand new? Because the production cost was lower, because I know for a fact this is the authors debut and the publisher prices it lower to help the author get a following. Her next book is already priced at $19.95.
This is a pointless argument. Go ask Microsoft why they don't price their product at 10% of what they currently do. They'll tell you because 90% of people are stealing their product and when Gates tried lower pricing, 90% of people still stole his software. I'd say 90% of people already get their books new at $5, it's only the fans who are willing to pay $30+ for a new book.