This is one of the worst first impressions for a service that I can recall. . .
My theory is that you started this app when Google Reader was discontinued. You then hastily put together whatever you could as fast as you could. Perhaps outsourced on elance or a similar website. Then slapped on a yearly price of 18.99 a year to capitalize on a hectic time.
I'm generally pretty nice with my comments on here, but this is ridiculous.