Hacker News Reader

Comment by onemorepassword | Hacker News Reader

I think you may also want to see this in the context of the US, where the Boy Scouts are an extremely bigoted organisation.

View on HN

Thank you, I did not know that and a quick google gives me plenty of links to start on.

It reminds me of when I was a "Cub", we had a couple of girl members and several female leaders. I didn't think anything of it at the time but I remember one lunch time one of the girl cubs (who went to my school) grabbed me (literally - she was two years older and bigger!) from playing football so I could tell a dinner lady who didn't believe that she was a cub. It was all in good fun but actually before that moment I'd never really got that one was for girls and one was for boys, I just thought you could choose freely. And, well, I suppose you can!

"Extremely bigoted" is a pretty unfair way to paint the Boy Scouts of America.

Agreed, it's just women, gays, and atheists who are discriminated against by the policies of the Boy Scouts of America.

So "bigoted" is probably more fair.

I don't know where you are, but my Troop has all of those. The national organization is pretty heavily Mormon, so that's an obstacle. But our Council just removed the rule against gay Scout.

And hey, the Girl Scouts are bigoted against boys, right? That's pretty disingenious; they are purpose-selective in accordance with massive issues with prepubescent youth. Pretty hard to mentor boys when they're constantly showing off to girls - try to change that!

Seems to work pretty well in countries that don't have different scout organizations for boys and girls.

I deny that; it seems implausible. But I have no more information than you.

You're right in that you have no more information about it than me. I spent some 8 years in such an organization so I probably know a lot more about it. It worked really well. Mixed troops are fairly common in the rest of the world.

Well, we have mixed Troops too, at the age of 14 and above, and its optional. But below that, a Boys-only club (and Girls-only as well of course) works pretty good for us.

I'm glad your experience was good. 8 years - so you must be an Eagle Scout? Or do you do that differently?

No, we don't have the concept of Eagle Scouts. We did have merit badges, but there wasn't much focus on getting them. We did spend a lot of time learning practical things that would help us on hikes.

What are you denying exactly? I am from Australia where they have mixed troops. Yes, it works pretty well.

I get the sarcasm, but I have to say it genuinely does piss me off if people consider hatred against gays or atheists to somehow be less offensive than racism or antisemitism.

The only real difference is the historical body count.

Don't you worry about devaluing the term "hatred" by throwing it around so lightly?

It's amusing that today, of all days, you are making this statement. http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/20/us/boy-scouts-move-to-lift...

Still banning gay leaders, though.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com