Hacker News Reader

Comment by JoeAltmaier | Hacker News Reader

Asteroids have negligible gravity. Solar wind is miniscule so far from the Sun (twice as far as the Earth, 1/10 the radiant effects). Mining generates prodigious amounts of dust. It would grow linearly until you were operating essentially in a dense field of dust. It would stay - maybe not 10,000 years, but forever for mining purposes.

View on HN

No, you'd be surprised. You can do an experiment where you just take 2 large masses (say bolders) and put them across from each other with a suspended balance-bar in the middle (suspended from the ceiling so that it spins freely). Over the night the bar will align to the masses via gravity.

Can't find the experiment because of no keywords for it I can think of, but this shows that even a few 100 kilos have real amounts of gravity.

Edit: Here it is: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavendish_experiment

My first reaction to this conversation was to imagine some kind of vacuum hose attachment. My second thought was "oh yeah... that won't work at all" :)

I had the same reaction - actually, I was thinking in some sort of spatial hoover - but I am still trying to work out in my mind if it would work. Can you explain how you came to the conclusion it wouldn't?

There's no air.

Exactly, I almost facepalmed when I realized the absurdity of a vacuum hose... although I do wonder if something along the lines of a CO2 compression canister would work to blow away dust. I'm assuming that it would be prohibitively expensive to have to constantly ship compressed gas to the mining site though.

That's why you'd just ship an asteroid that's already made of gas and liquid, and mine that for your gas.

"Evaporate some more nitrogen off that asteroid, Joe, we need to blow this dust away."

And to be specific, vaccums work by creating a low pressure locality inside of a gas. Same principle behind a backwards fan. Push the gas one way, you create a small low pressure point that other gas then fills. In a vaccume-cleaner the region of gas that can rush in to fill the low pressure point is at the end of a nozzle.

Really, you're not vacuuming up objects, they're just along for the ride in their immediate atmosphere.

(...And in space, you have no atmosphere to manipulate.)

It would have no way to generate suction. However, if you moved the space hover INTO the dust, you could have a mechanical trap inside.

EDIT: Looks like I was a bit late, I wrote this comment ~hour ago but didn't post it till now. :P

A roughly spherical asteroid of radius r has volume

4/3 * pi * r^3

Using Ceres as a benchmark for typical asteroid density, an asteroid of radius r has mass

[volume in meters^3] * 2077 kg/(m^3)

On the asteroid's surface, acceleration due to gravity is

[Gravitational constant] * [mass in kilograms] / (r in meters)^2

which simplifies to

(6.67384E-11 * 4/3 * pi * 2077 * r) m s^-2

If we mine on a 1km diameter asteroid, the dust we kick up will accelerate towards the surface at 2.9 * 10^-4 m/s^2. A dust cloud 10 meters high will settle in about five minutes.

Spin up the rock. Just make sure all of your equipment is bolted on tight.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com