Hacker News Reader

I would say that "each person in people" is a far cry from the type of logic in views normally frowned upon. What would you propose to be different in this case? Where does iteration of this type belong?

View on HN

Check out mustache. It has things that can be used for iteration but it isn't explicit and you decide what actually happens at runtime in code rather than in the template.

http://mustache.github.com

The {{#array}}item{{/array}} syntax is functionally equivalent to and equally logicless as {{#each array}}item{{/each}}, only the latter (handlebars) has the benefit of being precompilable and easily extensible by frameworks such as Ember, Meteor, and the like.

They may be equivalent, however, the first version has the freedom to do what they wish, for example, what is represented by array may not be directly iterable or it may be filtered. Precompilation is available in a variety of languages for mustache, including js.

IMOH, handlebars is a lazy version of mustache where the developer using it sacrifices maintainability and encapsulation. Which is probably ok for most apps that don't grow beyond a single developer.

Hogan.js by Twitter is a mustache implementation that supports precompilation, among other things.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com