Hacker News Reader

You're thinking only halfway

> similarly cmd+t closes a tab, wait cmd+w closes a tab not a window.

Because tabs are windows, and most multi-window-capable apps have the option to use tabs instead.

> and cmd+w in vlc does not close vlc

Again, in multi-window apps, closing the last window does not necessarily quit the app, but it's optional.

Consistent but optional, sounds inconsistent to me. Anyways that was 1 example, here's some more.

⌘R Reload in Safari; reply in Mail; reveal an alias's original in Finder

⌘L Address bar in browsers; message filter in Mail; clear to previous mark in Terminal.

⌘I File info in Finder; italics in text; inspector in Terminal.

I can keep going. This is not to say windows/osx is worse or better, just that claims of consistency are not suitable on either

"B" is "buy" in Counter-Strike, and "B" ls "look back" in a racing game.

What kind of consistency did you expect across Mail App and Safari? How do you "Reply" in browsers?

I am not expecting any consistency. I am expecting a claim of consistency NOT to be made for keyboard shortcuts either on osx or windows.

Okay so you’re being pedantic just for the sake of it. The shortcuts are about as consistent as they can be given the circumstances.