Now it's their problem to take care of, ignore, make fun of, or whatever, which was always ultimately going to be the case anyway.
This allows you to back with living your life while you still have one.
There's little point to bothering with predicting what the future will look like after you're dead, and even less point to trying to influence how others will behave on your behalf.
If you really want to have a lasting legacy of documentation, then build it and send it. Send it early, and send it often. Be the most interesting person on Earth today for your group.
Chances are fantastic that nobody will want to volunteer to build it for you after you're gone. But if it's important for you today, then make it easy on them: Send it right now.
...or don't. Really.
Telling some great stories at gatherings while perhaps sharing a couple of visual-reinforcement photos on a phone is enough unless you're a Kennedy or something. A wonderfully-interactive story is worth a thousand photographs. If you've got interesting stuff to share, then it will be interesting to hear, and to interact with, and it will remembered.
For awhile.
The best stories won't be chosen by you, but they'll be retold and will ebb and flow, and will subsequently die in a generation or three at most, but that's OK: You'll be dead, too. Get over it. By generation 4, those kids won't know who Uncle Fred was anyway except for a kind of sleepy myth about the carefully-preserved BD M-Disc archives (whatever those are) that were binned by Aunt Sally two decades prior because even Aunt Sally didn't care anymore, and couldn't be stuffed to keep them.
So keep living, and keep making and sharing new stories. Give people something to remember on their own accord. Don't force it, just do it and share it. Remember: If you were never very interesting to begin with, then they'll just bin whatever you left for them to discover when you're dead.
So be interesting. Live a decent and good life while you have it. Share it; no secrets. If it seems worth sharing after the funeral, then it's worth sharing right now.
(Except! In the odd chance that you are a Kennedy or something, then: Hire biographers. Hire them early, and often. Get that money, and line up the publishing of that stuff while you can still direct the proceeds. This is the path to preserving a legacy in a way that others can see down the road. (It might make it all the way to generation 5! (But it probably won't.)))
So why is it that photos >20 years old just aren't that interesting any more? Because photos need to be augmented by memories, or by stories from others. Once they're just pictures... and once I'm gone... no more interest.
We'd never throw out old physical photo albums. We have a cupboard full of them that my mom left behind. Some of the photos in them are of people we didn't even know, and now won't even know the names of. We keep them because we still have a little bit of connection to them - we knew the people to whom they were significant. But soon they'll just be landfill.
That's how human memory must work. We can't have every generation leave behind hundreds of thousands of pictures, piling up forever. Memories of past generations get purged until 2-3 generations back they're forgotten.
Of course there are exceptions to every rule. An uncle was persuaded to write his memoirs about his childhood on the farm in the middle of the last century. That will still be a good read after he, and those who knew him as a person, are gone. Assuming the books survive - it was a small, private printing only.
Whole lives of collecting sentimental goods all end up going in a giant bin, a whole house cleaned out in less than 2 hours. Photo albums are rarely kept, they just go in with it all and off to the tip usually in a single morning.
What you think is important to you, is basically just trash to your relatives/kids. They will probably have want they want before you are gone.
So my archiving needs are in the decades, not the centuries. If my kids can access them in 20 or 30 years, I will be happy.
I am skeptical of cloud services for such purposes because cloud services require ongoing maintenance: contractually, financially and technically.
The story furthermore must have enough intrinsic drama to engage readers, and fall into the hands of a writer with the skills to turn the raw facts into a biography.
The biographic text provides a structure to hang the photos on, yielding a "photobiography". Search for the term and you'll find examples.
Or just keep it attached to your system, so spyware, adware, and the NSA will make free backups for you!
The other thing I did was I ended up collecting HDD's out of old DVR's people were throwing out. Those drives are used for cold storage but not for anything important because they already have tens of thousands of hours on them and in not the best temperature conditions. Again, non have failed yet.
Funnily enough, the only HDD I have failing is a 2.1GB Quantum Fireball from 1997 in my Pentium 1! Really should swap that for an SD card via IDE.
It was a special system, Linux-based, running proprietary software for expensive proprietary hardware.
I apologized profusely. I got them some new hard drives coming right away. I found a forgettable donor drive in the boneyard that had a close-enough footprint for the connector, harvested it with hot air, and put its connector onto one of the broken client drives.
A little bit of dd and some mdadm magic later, and they were back in business with that RAID-1 array like it never happened (other than just a few days of downtime on a system they only used occasionally).
---
A different time, 25 or more years ago now, I somehow broke a 4-pin Molex[2] power connector off of one of my own IDE drives. I don't remember the details, but I do remember that I fixed it by soldering a Y cable power splitter into the holes on the board. This gave me a drive that worked, and that had power pass-through. It was kind of nice to have (and it worked for years and years after that).
Anyway, I guess shit happens sometimes.
---
[1] I wasn't rough with anything; I was just moving wiring out of the way, as one does, to attack the dust bison that had accumulated over the previous decade or more with some canned air.
I somehow broke the connectors of both drives, anyway. I can't explain it and I don't have to, so I guess I won't bother trying. They were fine when I started and they were broken when I finished.
[2]: Those aren't Molex connectors. Everyone calls 'em that, like everyone calls adhesive bandages Band-Aids, but the old drives used a design characterized by the Amphenol Mate-N-Lok connector design which had nothing to do with Molex.
I've been programming for 50 years now. I've had all sorts of failures, including two incidents of my desktop computer burst into flames.
I now set the desktop on a piece of sheet steel. I also only use steel enclosures for them.
I have a Carver amp that runs 24/7 in my office, for the last 40 years. It's now emitting a 60 cycle hum, which I learned is due to decaying capacitors. I guess I need to get a cap kit and fix it.
Being even remotely relevant to future generations is quite another.
I had so many of my users ask your question that I wrote this up: https://photostructure.com/guide/how-do-i-safely-store-files...
But a month or two after I initially wrote that, my brother and I found a couple boxes of photos from my parents and grandparents. No notes. No dates. No albums. Just envelopes and envelopes of undated photos.
Taking the time to make an annotated printed photo book, including dates, people and place names, and any other context is going to make those images a lot less irrelevant to future generations, and printed media, stored well, should easily last 50-100 years.
I would not make a bet that you'll be able to procure a bdxl reader in that time period.
The problem with archiving data is you always need to be prepared to use the "next big thing" once your preferred method becomes unobtainable.
I currently have :
- Photos in iCloud (Live working copy)
- Backup at home on NAS (updated nightly, snapshots)
- Backup in pCloud (lifetime, mine or theirs, no illusions, hopefully lasts a couple of months if I die unexpectedly)
- Yearly archive on external HDDs, identical copies stored in separate locations, clearly labeled "Photo backup". No encryption, no archiving, just plain APFS formatted drives that can be plugged into a computer and read.
- Yearly archive M-disc blu-ray discs, again, identical copies, stored in separate locations. One disc per year labeled as such, ie. "Photo Backup 2020". The idea being you restore them in chronological order and have a complete set.
I occasionally look at my own, but that's about it.
If an album is well annotated with dates and locations and names and descriptions, it might be fun, but I suspect the number of old photo albums with this kind of effort put in them is rare.
And the crazy thing is - we actually watch home movies in a linear format as a consequence. Rather than picking a clip here and a clip there amongst a sea of photos, video can be laid out in a linear timeline and watched without editing.
(I still use a professional Panasonic video camera that shoots AVCHD, which makes this super easy. Because editing video is not something I'm ever likely to have time to do)
This is an _additional_ layer of backups, on top of the usual iCloud/whatever things. LTO is certainly not user-friendly, but neither is it especially user-hostile.
And I think I trust tapes far better than any other alternative for long-term storage as they have by far the smallest areal density of information compared to disks (hard or optical).
I have DVD disks that are barely 10 years old and that I can't read anymore. Hard drives also die in storage and/or during transport.
Recently the computer museum helped recover early 1970s unix tapes. It was a big deal.
And let's not exaggerate the complexity of setting up external tape drives, even on Windows/macOS.
Having found a matching Sun Ultra 5 generation drive, I tried to get it to work with a SCSI card, and had .. many many problems. It may be the rubber bands. It may be stiction. it may be ants. It may be me.
I would personally love to de-exaggerate the complexitity: Old hardware is gnarly. I sourced parts, it wasn't working.
And yeah, I started with a ZX-Spectrum with cassette tapes. I was pleasantly surprised by the overall LTO experience.
I wonder if there is a better printing technology comparable to analog "prints" (of film). That would actually make more sense (to me) than saving everything on M-Disc.
- A photo album extended with a curated set of photos each year. The real deal!
- NAS at [my] home and blu-ray off site (parents home) for all photos
Updated: added [my] for clarification