Hacker News Reader

Comment by dnautics | Hacker News Reader

I don't think the zig community is necessarily hostile to LLMs, they just don't want it in their "maintained by 10-ish core people not even full time" language impl. Mitchell Hashimoto, a big zig contributor (both money and effort), for example, uses LLMs a lot and no particular shade is thrown.

View on HN

This is from my own first hand experience both on ziggit forums as well as raising bugs in zig repository. My account on codeberg is still banned on zig repository without any single comment, my issues or pull request raised on that project just went in ether without being accessible, if you see the issue yourself could have made the decision if it was warranted to ban the account, but that right also taken by the core contributor out of spite and disdain for LLM.

I have been in open source world with linux kernel since 1992, never every had seen a community so hostile, especially towards humans who spend time and efforts just out of curiosity, inquisitiveness and trying to support some simple alternative when odds are already against them.

Facing hostile behavior from inside the community made me switch to odin language where they also do not use LLM but are pragmatic about people using it. Cannot comment on Mitchell because I do not contribute with money.

I mean I pr'd something (and it was not accepted) but the grounds have nothing to do with LLMs. I'm pretty vocal about using LLMs to write zig code. Obviously I did not use LLMs in my PR

I would be fine if they reject the PR, given I was first time raising it to fix POSIX related issue. It was just few lines of code. But my account was banned all issues removed my own PR not visible and looked like tyrannical approach not a benevolent dictator approach. I think being nice to another human being is the basis for building community. Here felt like if you are among the few who dictate the terms there is no process just my way or highway.

Well, it's Codeberg. They ban people just for using LLMs.

It is not codeberg, I can work on other repository properly on it. Its only zig repository where my account is blocked. My initial thought was same as you, only later realized it. Also on ziggit these people did the same even though based on policy when I put the post i clearly mentioned use of LLM. This all without any proper communication. After working on zig for over 6 months, now I am moving slowly to odin [1] language. This decision I did not take lightly, I had spend significant resources in zig earlier and now moving away.

[1] https://odin-lang.org/

You sound really fun to collaborate with.

> My account on codeberg is still banned

> my account was banned because my projects on github using zig uses LLM.

Its not Zig. Its codeberg. Codeberg has a strict no-AI policy. Codeberg is ALL about the community and not the lone hacker. I think its a good policy to prevent overload and clearly distinguish project ecosystems from each other.

https://blog.codeberg.org/protecting-our-floss-commons-from-...

They said that their projects on GitHub use LLM, not on Codeberg.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com