Hacker News Reader

Comment by nalekberov | Hacker News Reader

Never buy a recertified drive, talking from my own experience, my recertified Seagate Exos X16 failed exactly after a year. They are very cheap for a reason.

It failed for a reason before, so it will likely fail again before the end of its usual lifecycle.

View on HN

This has not been my experience at all. All of my NAS drives are recertified enterprise models. I've never had one fail. (But then I've only had a single spinning disk fail on me ever. Generally I retire them because they become too small to justify occupying a slot. Slots are scarce.)

How long have they been spinning 24/7?

idk, it was such a traumatic experience for me that I decided to pass on recertified HDDs.

A really long time (at least by residential standards). Close to 24/7 for many years.

If a single HDD failing is traumatic then you're doing something wrong. At absolute minimum you should be in raid1. Backups should amount to snapshots that can be restored in a single step.

> If a single HDD failing is traumatic then you're doing something wrong. At absolute minimum you should be in raid1. Backups should amount to snapshots that can be restored in a single step.

I wasn't storing anything important on it anyway, mostly movies ripped from Blu-rays. So its failure wasn't traumatic. However I expected it to last at least three years, but it died after exactly 365 days of use. The seller refused to send a replacement, and legally speaking, they were in the right.

Melodramatic mutch? The first new IDE HDD I ever bought died within a week. The first new USB HDD I ever bought was dead on arrival. My first server SSD became read only after a year.

Better telling everyone not to buy this things. /s

Thanks for the textbook definition of a logical fallacy, buddy. (Your idiocy has no limits)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com