I don't like it when people take mumbo-jumbo that can't be pinned down, or measured, or even agreed upon, and try to insist that we should base decision-making on it. It's literally just vibes with extra steps.

The "far more important and consequential" thing you're touting is your ability to make decisions based purely on vibes. And not even consistent, broadly agreed-upon vibes like "murder is pretty bad". It's vibes of the most vile variety: "sentience is what I decided sentience is".

An average internet user is sentient, but a 1996 Nissan ECU isn't. Why? Because I said so. Tremble before my might!