I made this same reply to another thread, so I'm sorry to say essentially the same thing twice, but -- the comment has a familiar structure, "it doesn't work for you because you used an [old / suboptimal / non-frontier] model. If you use X you'll see that it works". These sorts of claims push the onus back onto the other person (or in this case tfa), without really accepting the result, or taking on any work for yourself. It gets tiresome to retest with the newest model every other week. Is there any data you can provide to support your claim, or any result you can contribute here?

Yeah, it’s crazy how fast things have changed in a month. I couldn’t find a more recent replication or similar study but it would be interesting to see it done with the current frontiers. Though I don’t think that would change much about the overall conclusion of the paper