Hacker News Reader

Great project but I believe Google Photos pricing is quite reasonable and alluring.

I've always considered using something like this but the fact that it's backed up locally (to backup on cloud I have to pay for another service) and not accessible to my family kind of puts me off from setting up something like this

View on HN

Google Photos is a great value proposition, but it's still only 1 copy in 1 medium. If you count your phone as another copy/medium you still need a 3rd copy somewhere if you want to follow the 3-2-1 backup strategy.

> not accessible to my family

My family has no trouble with it, the UX is excellent. My retirement age parents are regularly adding photos to shared albums and things like that.

Why would it not be accessible to your family? Immich allows sharing links

It is possible in general, but almost everybody doing self hosting (and as outlined in the article) does it on a local network and not on the internet. Most people that self host don't want to have to be a sysadmin in their free time in order to have a reasonable risk of not leaking all your families photos to the internet.

There is an immich proxy project: https://github.com/alangrainger/immich-public-proxy

I wouldn't make the instance itself public, but I think this is a decent tradeoff. Of course still requires one to be a sysadmin.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com