Be careful to not overstate the conclusion of that blog post - best of 3 wins when the cache update rate is more frequent than average task duration, and best of 2 still has herding behavior and loses to 1 random when the update rate is less frequent (which may be high load, or we may also be missing a dimension here). Since the plot chose the window where best of 2 wins, it might bias or prime the reader to believe best of 2 is usually or always best, forgetting that underloaded and overloaded scenarios are in reality more common than all servers having a nice balanced medium size load for long periods.