Hacker News Reader

It is on the Wayback Machine (NSFW of course)

https://web.archive.org/web/19991111060504/http://www.goatse...

It’s still around, I got inadvertently goatse’d this year (after not encountering the damned thing for 15 years)

The fact is that 99.99% of Internet users nowadays solely exist within sanitised content siloes, and that includes Google Search.

Part of me says nothing of value was lost but you formulate it so eloquent that it is a shame that the cultural reference is lost

The original site is long gone, but the image still exists at similar URLs. Though from the description on KnowYourMeme, apparently no one has duplicated the original site, so there's a second image that has been forgotten.