If a contract dated to the 4th October 1582 specifies you have 15 days to make payment, you would indeed need to know where that contract was signed to determine on what day that deadline expired.

And if there is a contract dated to the 6th October 1582, that does raise questions about its legitimacy (though in general misdating a contract does not void it, it would merely be one point of evidence in your argument that it's a forgery, just like using a particular font in a modern printed contract)