Hacker News Reader

Comment by monk_grilla | Hacker News Reader

I don't know I think it is charming in a way that is lacking in nearly everything else an LLM tries to do creatively.

I have always preferred the result of getting an LLM to draw an svg or make a procedural animation like this to the uncanny hyper-realistic result of diffusion image/video generation.

View on HN

To help explain AI to my elderly mother, I said it is like an alien intelligence on a planet too far away to directly observe Earth, and everything it knows about humanity and our world it learned from reading just about every book and website. You can ask it a question or to do some work and it can often give a useful response but it can never directly judge its accuracy if it relates to the physical world, it has only your judgment to work with.

Given that limitation, it is incredible what it can still accomplish. And when it falls short, it is often in a charming way, if you are open to seeing it that way. It reflects something like a child's understanding of the world, not entirely wrong, just incomplete.

The fluttering cubes that might have been bees or butterflies were my favorite part.

That's a nice metaphor for your mother, i like it. I would just touch on one small part, which is that it has more than our judgement though. It has access to laws of physics, to formulas, to all our current scientific knowledge which we have shown to be correct by interacting with the physical world. It can create an (incomplete) model of the world based on verified theories already. Through deduction and reasoning alone it can get pretty far. After all, there's many scientific theories we created long in advance before we actually proved them to be correct through interaction with the physical world. So even before they were proved to be correct, they were already correct. Same can be applied to what LLM can infer through reasoning alone.

Anyway, just a small point which probably still wouldn't change the nice metaphor your made.

That's true, on some level it is capable of reasoning about the physical world even beyond our ability, through sheer breadth of knowledge and stamina. I suppose the area where it relies most on our judgment is about subjective experience, and this better explains its limitations.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com