Hacker News Reader

As if ALL OF THAT doesn't represent inherent and crucial elements of judgement, and therefore"intelligence" itself.

We are not purely rational creatures, thank God. Sometimes those "limiting factors" you listed -- stress, peer pressure, hormones -- are crucial elements of informing the problem solving process and arriving at a decision or a solution that actually works.

All an LLM can do is fulfill a prompt, no matter how misguided, backwards, or incomplete that prompt actually was.

"Go jump off a bridge." Hmm. Dying makes me stressed out. I'm not gonna do that.

IMO we won’t see AGI until the models are sitting inside bodies with senses and gut biomes and opposable thumbs and the like, all influencing the context window in real time. Intelligence is a full-bodied experience

That's a bit like saying a tail is swayed by a dog, as if it could exist without one, or would have anything to do if it did.

Why does it matter? This is completely based on data produced by humans.