edit:
To me it looks like yours has the following negative qualities:
- closed source
- requires signup for some service
- says code doesnt leave my machine but this connects to your servers
- requires Goose AI as a dependency
- Baseline it. We mine previous logs, github comments, etc. for "what you care about." That helps pull out decisions that you actually care to read.
- Anchor to code. "The code enshrines this decision" is more interesting than "the agent self-talked this." Agents don't always self-talk decisions, and the thing that ultimately matters is the behavior in code.
to your edit (and all totally fair):
- Yes, closed source and signup required. A lot of what we're driving towards is easy team sharing, so we're taking the bath early instead of building an OSS thing and rug-pulling later.
- Code doesn't leave your machine. There's an agent that runs locally. I know "trust me" isn't the strongest stance, but this comes from the multi-player future.
- Honestly, Goose AI is a remnant of a previous product. It's inert and we'll clean it up once we've gotten the last couple folks off the previous iteration.
I agree agents don't always self-talk decisions, that's why we distill the whole transcript after the fact instead of asking them to log anything. Your baselining idea is good!