Hacker News Reader

> The banks are run by goblins with big noses.

I can believe that the origins of this trope are antisemetic, but I don't see very much reason to think that any antisemitic mindset was in JK Rowling's head when she wrote it.

View on HN

That's a real stretch. She copied a modern day trope, not some ancient myth with unclear origin. Even if we bend over backwards to believe that she wasn't aware that the trope targeted a specific demographic, there's zero chance that her publisher failed to catch it too. And also the entire movie staff that chose floors with seven pointed stars for the bank. Also also consider that this trope is far from an isolated case in the whole series.

It just doesn't make that much sense to me. "And also the entire movie staff that chose floors with seven pointed stars for the bank" - so the entire movie staff is antisemitic? And what is the connection between a seven pointed star and Judaism / antisemitism anyway?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com