Hacker News Reader

Comment by agrona | Hacker News Reader

Fire drills strike me as an infrequent yet important safety measure. Unless it's some management term I don't understand?

View on HN

When someone else's lack of preparation or planning makes it your last-minute problem. NOT the life-saving kind.

I have long wondered how the phrase came to mean this, because when it happens, it's never a drill.

You go through all the pomp and circumstance like it actually mattered, even though the majority of the people running around know it doesn't.

Perhaps it is a politically-correct version of this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_fire_drill which includes the substitution of mere activity (all hands on deck & running around) in place of the desired results.

The vast majority of business firedrills are arbitrarily caused by someone wanting a deadline met for no particular reason.

Everyone does crunch time not because there is actually a pressing emergency, but because the company wishes to extract additional effort for no additional pay.

Hm, ok. That's not been my experience. For example, I have definitely heard it used in Operations contexts to describe broken shit that needs fixing now -- things that are real problems and not drills. "Drill" to me implies preparation for an event in the future like a test or an emergency.

I imagine it's due to the superficial similarities, i.e. a bunch of people running around not really knowing what they should be doing, but in a big hurry.

We use it to mean practising how we handle bad things, such as unexpected server failures, which seems to me a reasonable appropriation of the term.

I think the poster misspoke and they meant, "fire-fighting."

This makes a lot of sense to me, and might explain what's going on with the puzzling uses of "fire drill" I've witnessed in recent years. I almost want to say that there's been a shift in jargon going on, because I feel like I hear people talk about fighting fires at work less often than I used to say, a decade ago.

To the degree that it's systematic, I'd say it's probably a perjoration as people became uncomfortable talking about fighting in the workplace (or whatever).

Reply on news.ycombinator.com