The person you're replying to isn't me (the person you're quoting above), but to be clear:

I'm not trying to be insulting, here, it's just kind of a bizarre, eyebrow-raising thing to see. There's a reason you're not seeing any AAA games doing this, y'know?

If you're doing something that's really unusual, you're going to have people going "this is really unusual".

Please don't take this the wrong way - this is sincere, well-intentioned advice: have you ever watched Shark Tank? The best people on there can still give a good pitch when their ideas are challenged.

The games industry - and especially the multiplayer games space - are brutal, and players are going to be way more critical, way more rudely, than anyone on HN.

It would benefit you and your game greatly to practice selling your idea in the face of criticism and doubt.